As written it’s correct (provided that God parted the heavens, leaned down, and whispered “8%” in your ear); if this is as far as you went in that thread, then it was a mistake to link back to your postings (maybe it was **Huerta88 **who was saying wrong things?). But–and I don’t mean this to sound rude–a big part of the reason you’re right is that you haven’t actually said anything. Yes, if you know nothing at all, then you can apply population statistics to the general population. You will never know nothing at all, so this is an empty statement. It’s the equivalent of me (as a non-lawyer) saying “things that are illegal are against the law.” Great as far as it goes, but probably not necessary to say, and missing the point in a discussion of whether a particular activity is illegal.