John Tyler
Millard Fillmore
Calvin Coolidge
Harry S Truman
I assume “they were all Presidents” is too general… Did they all succeed to the Presidency from the Vice-Presidency? I know that Tyler and Truman did.
Oh, and this one isn’t original to me, but it’s too good not to share:
The USS Fletcher
An unseasonable frost in Florida
A hula hoop with a nail in it
Specifically, each succeeded someone who died in office – William Henry Harrison, Zachary Taylor, Warren G. Harding, and FDR, respectively.
Brahe had a fake nose, and Jackson’s nose wan’t the one he was born with either.
Pass to someone else until I hopefully get the hang of posing the problem.
Oops- sorry i somehow missed several posts.
Not what I was going for. Here’s another one to add to the list:
Wish You Were Here
Previous:
One
Creep
Bitch
(And no, one-syllable words isn’t it either.)
Need EVEN more specific! 
- NY Jets quarterback Joe Namath
- Heart surgeon Michael DeBakey
- “The Odd Couple” star Tony Randall
- Defense Secretary Robert McNamara
- Comedian Bill Cosby
- Alabama Governor George Wallace
- Scientist/left-wing activist Noam Chomsky
- Short story author O. Henry
- TV comedian Tim Allen
- Boxing promoter Don King
- Glam rock star David Bowie
- “Batman” star Michael Keaton
- “Scaramouche” star Stewart Granger
- Singer Katy Perry
Changed their last name because a more famous person already had it.
1.Jones
2.Douglas
3. unsure
4.Hudson
Absolutely right!
Before he came to Hollywood, Stewart Granger was “Jimmy Stewart” to all his friends.
spent time in prison
A naval/navel destroyer.
Quite right
- White House Press Secretary Ron Nessen
- “This Is Spinal Tap” director Rob Reiner
- “I Love Lucy” co-star Desi Arnaz
- Singer/songwriter Paul Simon
- Sex symbol Raquel Welch
All were titles of two (or more) otherwise unrelated songs:
Wish You Were Here: Eddie Fisher/Pink Floyd
One: Three Dog Night/the cast of ‘A Chorus Line’/U2/Metallica
Creep: Radiohead/TLC
Bitch: The Rolling Stones/Meredith Brooks
Hosted “Saturday Night Live” during its first season
Correct!
OK, that’s ironic. I was considering looking them up to see if they were all the same artist, but then I said “Nah, there are a ton of songs titled “One”; it’d be a pain to try to track them all down”.