Public librarian chiming in.
You can get an undergraduate degree in anything. I’ve met a wide variety of people with BAs in all sorts of topics. And even some with BS degrees.
The MLS is a necessary evil. It’s not a very exciting program in my opinion. But you’ve got to do it. If it’s any consolation, the classes are not overwhelmingly difficult. Besides, the types of classes offered now are so different from what I took back in the old days of 1988.
If you want to go into public librarianship, you should be able to find a job quite easily. Most systems have many openings. Of course, you may not wish to be a children’s or a YA librarian. If you do, you’re set. You will be snapped and wined and dined and recruited to no end. And if you’re not a total idiot, you will be promoted very quickly. Children and YA positions are quite visible positions in a library and the people that run libraries like seeing kids in reading programs and such. Gets TV and newspaper people to the library.
If you want to work on the adult side, there will be a little more competition. Also, a lot depends upon where you work. If you work in a small library, you better like the people you work with. Or else you will be in for a miserable 40 hours/week.
If you want to work in an academic library, the competition is quite fierce. Those jobs are highly prized (although for the life of me I can’t figure out why). Academic librarians, in addition to doing reference work, also have to teach classes and undertake research and get published and all sorts of crap like that. Why do that when you can waste company time on the Internet.
And academic librarians don’t get paid much more (often less) than public librarians. YMMV.
One thing about public libraries you need to remember is the word PUBLIC. Pretty much anybody can walk into a public library. And pretty much everybody does. Many of these people have no homes. Or they have no jobs. Or they are kids whose parents dump them there.
You may have to deal with: patrons pulling knives on each other to figure out who is entitled to a particular public Internet station, or just resorting to fists. The latter happened today and the former happened Saturday. Or you may find people having sex in the public restroom. Or shooting heroin. Or using books and furniture as TP.
I mention these in the spirit of full disclosure. There is a certain image that people have of libraries. They think they are nice quiet contemplative places.
After 14 years of working in them, I haven’t found one that is like that.
This is not to say I don’t like my job. I am well remunerated. I get to learn new stuff every day. I get to learn about computer technology and I get some really fast Internet access for free whenever I want it.
And as a guy, I can say that being a librarian is an instant way to get an attractive woman to run far, far, far away from you. One day that woman won’t be able to run away fast enough and then I’ll settle down and get married.