Logological discovery

Since I was a kid, I’ve always been fascinated by groups of words that differ only by changing the five vowels: bag, beg, big, bog and bug are all actual words.

Today, out of the blue, I discovered blander, blender, blinder, blonder and blunder.
Whaddya know?

Tan ten tin ton tun!

logological starts with “logo logi” but you already knew that

There’s also blynder, since “blynd” is an archaic spelling for “blind”, though that doesn’t add to your list a word with an entirely new meaning.

R_d. I did have to look up rud, but supposedly it’s a valid scrabble word. I imagine there are a lot of 3 and 4 letter variants that qualify where one of the vowels forms an archaic word.

It turns out that someone who writes bots has a job title the same as a “Flat-bottomed Dutch sailing vessel,” so there’s always that.

This is a job for … software!
My quick & dirty script produced these 98 results.

amber ember imber omber umber
an en in on un
are ere ire ore ure
as es is os us
back beck bick bock buck
bad bed bid bod bud
bag beg big bog bug
ball bell bill boll bull
bally belly billy bolly bully
ban ben bin bon bun
band bend bind bond bund
bander bender binder bonder bunder
bang beng bing bong bung
bat bet bit bot but
brat bret brit brot brut
chack check chick chock chuck
chacker checker chicker chocker chucker
clack cleck click clock cluck
dab deb dib dob dub
dacker decker dicker docker ducker
dae dee die doe due
daer deer dier doer duer
dag deg dig dog dug
dan den din don dun
fad fed fid fod fud
fally felly filly folly fully
fat fet fit fot fut
gad ged gid god gud
gally gelly gilly golly gully
gan gen gin gon gun
gat get git got gut
hack heck hick hock huck
hall hell hill holl hull
hap hep hip hop hup
hat het hit hot hut
lack leck lick lock luck
lagger legger ligger logger lugger
lane lene line lone lune
last lest list lost lust
lat let lit lot lut
late lete lite lote lute
ma me mi mo mu
male mele mile mole mule
malt melt milt molt mult
man men min mon mun
mang meng ming mong mung
mare mere mire more mure
mass mess miss moss muss
massiness messiness missiness mossiness mussiness
massy messy missy mossy mussy
mate mete mite mote mute
na ne ni no nu
nab neb nib nob nub
nat net nit not nut
pack peck pick pock puck
paddle peddle piddle poddle puddle
pall pell pill poll pull
pan pen pin pon pun
pant pent pint pont punt
pap pep pip pop pup
pappy peppy pippy poppy puppy
pass pess piss poss puss
pat pet pit pot put
patter petter pitter potter putter
rab reb rib rob rub
rack reck rick rock ruck
rad red rid rod rud
rag reg rig rog rug
rat ret rit rot rut
rax rex rix rox rux
road roed roid rood roud
sack seck sick sock suck
san sen sin son sun
sare sere sire sore sure
slad sled slid slod slud
snab sneb snib snob snub
snack sneck snick snock snuck
spat spet spit spot sput
sprang spreng spring sprong sprung
stang steng sting stong stung
stark sterk stirk stork sturk
strang streng string strong strung
ta te ti to tu
taa tae tai tao tau
tack teck tick tock tuck
tae tee tie toe tue
tag teg tig tog tug
tale tele tile tole tule
tan ten tin ton tun
tang teng ting tong tung
tanner tenner tinner tonner tunner
tate tete tite tote tute
toa toe toi too tou
unstack unsteck unstick unstock unstuck
wad wed wid wod wud
wan wen win won wun
wat wet wit wot wut

I have a feeling that not all of those words would be allowed even in Scrabble. :nerd_face:

daer?
gud?
roed?
steng?
taa?
wod?
and many more.

And others are either abbreviations (deg), archaic ('pon), or prefixes (mult).

A fun list, but dictionary.com is snobbish.

My favourite set.

Never been told to “git gud, newb”? :slight_smile:

“Filled with roe” - perfectly cromulent

That one has at least 3 valid meanings

Although I agree that a lot of them don’t work. Roed does, but roud doesn’t, for example.

My word list does have a lot of obscure and archaic words, but the six you call out are all in the OED.

daer: A beast: usually a quadruped, as distinguished from birds and fishes; but sometimes, like beast , applied to animals of lower orders. Obsolete .

gud: A euphemistic for god [n. and int.]

roed: Of a fish: carrying roe; full of spawn.

steng: dialectical for sting and stang in various senses

taa: archaic form of take

wod: variant of several words including void, wood, weed, wit, etc.

And “roud” is defined as
English regional ( Norfolk ). Now rare . intransitive . Of a fish: to spawn.

You can consider this list to be a superset of an acceptable list.

So is there a formal term for this sort of wordplay?

When I read this list, I pronounced the bolded word in my head as rhyming with “tinder”, and thought: “Blinnder?? That’s not a word!!”

Mmmm - addictive. I feel the need have a Y word too:

Dane
Dene
Dine
Done
Dune
Dyne

j

“Logology” was coined by Dmitri A. Borgmann to represent the study of recreational linguistics. He founded Word Ways, a magazine devoted to this pursuit, along with writing a couple of books on the subject.

Thank you very much for this list. It’s going in my vade mecum now.

I don’t care about the new meaning bit. I’ve checked the OED and W2, and they agree with you. So, huzzah!

Word Ways is still being produced quarterly by Butler University, IN. Here is its website complete with access to some free back issues.

Yeah, I always wanted to add “y” to the group, but they’re about as rare as hen’s teeth.

I’m a lot less picky than Scrabble or dictionary.com. Abolete archaisms are fine with me. :grinning: