**Vote Count:
Astral(7): Chronos, USCDiver, Innerstickler, Snickers, Drainbead, Hoopy, Doctorwho
Peeker(5): Oneandonly, Nanook, MHaye, Guiri, Meeko
Cucuy(1): Peeker
**
and please don’t take this wrong folks.
but i really am going to take my wins and losses from this board and chart them separately. if i look back on the last 10 games i have played every loss has been on this board as town. of course the one time that i was vigging every freaking townie that i could find will stay on the board. but the rest of 'em, meh.
wanderer is scum as well as chronos. probably throw a lurker in there as well.
based on the disclosed firepower of town as well as information not in the game thread there are most likely five scum. any less and it makes no sense.
good luck folks, and when i flip town look at who started this run. you betcha there are scum there. obviously wanderer and most likely mhaye.
that’s all i’ve got.
and just to put it on the record because i love being right
unvote
vote wanderer
I believe you Peeker.
That is all you got.
That is, you are lying about the rest. At least you admit it now.
**
You would be doing it right now. **
Peeker, you want me to take your word that Wanderer and Chronos is Scum, but you wont tell me why I should believe you ?
**
And you don’t see anything wrong here? **
**
And you don’t a problem reconciling Hiding things that you don’t have to hide against the concept of Town motivation? **
It would seem I have a problem with dropping full words, here, lately.
I think is a mischaracterization of the point I was trying to make. I never insisted that Sauron was NOT in the game. I simply state that Town aligned players should maintain a level of skepticism about purported roles or characters included in a closed set-up game. You did not seem to share my skepticism and I took that as a scum tell.
after the game is over or we are both dead i will tell you what happened. promise.
here’s a pm for you. since you folks seem to like that kind of shit.
mafia
if what ed posted just now is true you get the bastard of all times award.
and i will play it that way, just to let you know.
but at least we got a little action. when i come out with boromir it ought to be a feeding frenzy. either that or these folks don’t deserve the level of effort that the mods put into the games.
woot woot.
Uh, peeker, you do realize that there are other players playing the game, right? So when someone asks “what was the crappy Town play”, you’re expected to answer something a little more than “You’re Scum”. And even if you did know that Wanderers and I were Scum (which I know you don’t, since I am in fact Town), it doesn’t do diddly for you to know that if nobody else does, which means that you should kind of explain your reasons to the rest of us.
Ah, well. Once Astral, whom you’re certain is Town but whom you insisted we should have killed, is dead, it’ll become apparent just how hard you’ve been working to avoid lynching Scum. Well, even more apparent, at least.
here is one more just to make your head hurt. in a good way hopefully.
mafia
ok, if ed and i make it to the morning this fucker is coming unglued.
sorry chronos such was not the intent.
i think it was a crappy town play to go down the handshake path. i think you saying you knew who aragorn was unnecessary. i think that whole nonsense on Day 1 was terrible. but you know the person who insitigated it was town. just kind of goes to show you that not good for town does not equate to scum.
i don’t know that you are town chronos (and to be honest the more you shout it the less convinced i become). the only person that has claimed the same level of knowledge that you have is scum. jeez two equals two in my book. and i fully anticipate that you will disagree and that would be expected so no great shakes or hard feelings there.
and the worst of times come across us. i could have kept my yippity shut and let astral swing. but now it looks like a certain cadre will put my neck in the noose. one more town gone and then back to the astral conundrum.
but now that i think about it.
unvote
vote cucuy (or whatever)
because i think you and wanderer are scum. but i know that non participation is anti game. which i find a much more heinous offense.
my two cents, ymmv, etc.
Fuck this… I don’t want to wait until Tomorrow anymore. **peeker **Today, **Astral **Tomorrow.
**unvote Astral
vote Peeker **
The only person that has claimed the same level of knowledge I have is me.
Here’s another question: If you’re so all-fired certain that Wanderers and I are both Scum, what would that say if one of us were to flip Town? Would you say that would be enough justification for everyone else to lynch you?
certainly. as long as you go along with when i flip town they lynch you.
By the way: USCDiver’s vote switch puts us at 6-6, with Astral, cucuy, and (effectively) peeker not voting. Astral is currently still the lynch designee, as I understand the tiebreaker rules, since he reached 6 votes before peeker did. cucuy hasn’t posted in over two weeks, so I think it’s safe to say he’s not doing anything in the game any more, so it’ll come down to whether and when our two potential lynchees place self-defense votes: If neither does, then it’s Astral, and if they do, whoever places their vote first lives. Frankly, I think it odd that neither one of them has placed a meaningful vote yet.
No, that part only follows if you can give an actual reason for being certain I’m Scum. You’re the one who swears you’re certain, so you have to bear the responsibility for that. That’s how it works.
Why, exactly, is it odd that I haven’t voted yet? As the lynch designee, I was spending my time mulling over the game. I’ve been looking over at everyone, collecting my thoughts, and I plan on putting them down in-game before I die. I’ll vote when I’m good and ready.
However, I haven’t decided who strikes me as most scummy yet. And a defensive vote on Peeker right this second does town no good, if it’s motivated solely to save myself. If I decide that he’s most scummiest, I’ll vote him then. Until that moment, it’s Peeker’s game to vote for me or not.
Hey Mahaloth, is there some sort of system in place to deal with non-players like Cucuy? If he hasn’t posted in two weeks, will you eventually modkill him?
I’d like to know if I have to bother looking through his posts for my final write-up or not. 
See Astral, you say things like that and that’s part of the reason people think you’re scum.
Let’s assume for a second that you are in fact Town. I don’t believe this, but let’s go with it for a moment. You do not, and in fact cannot, know that peeker is Town. However, you DO know that you yourself are Town. Therefore a defensive vote, from your standpoint, is a positive thing. You are definately contributing to the saving of a Town player.
That said, once again I think you are scum. And as such, don’t feel like giving you that chance.
** unvote peeker
vote Astral **