On thinking about this some more, the XO won’t have any power toMorrow, since toMorrow will be the last Day anything matters. And I trust myself and Scuba_Ben more than Cookies, so I’d rather have one of us in the Security seat, since it’s conceivable that Security might still be able to do something. Therefore,
Promote Cookies
Now, then. What I’m thinking is that toMorrow, if Hal is innocent and there’s still a Night-kill, I’ll ask ColdPhoenix to put out a warrant on himself, and Cookies to vote for herself. If either doesn’t cooperate, I’ll vote for that person. Then, at the last minute, if everyone’s still in compliance, I’ll make a post executing the arrest order and voting for Cookies. That will leave me, a confirmed Town, as the sole remaining player outside the Brig, which is effectively a Town win condition. Of course, if Scuba is alive instead of me, he could do the same thing.
This is vulnerable to Cookies, if she’s Scum, unvoting herself at the last minute, but I think I have better odds of beating that than I do of picking between the two of them.
Man, I hope Hal is Scum.