Can we start the killing, now?
Woof. The first day is gonna be brutal.
Nah, the first Day is going to me arguing against all comers for a No Lynch.
Or, is that what you were referring to? 
No argument from me. No lynch is clearly the way to go. Finding the single mafioso is going to be like looking for a needle in a haystack. There is a MUCH better chance we will accidentally kill a power role. And since the…well I guess I should wait for the game to actually start before I start rambling.
Have we started yet?
I am so psyched for this game. I’ve decided I much prefer village-setting, complete-with-power-roles Mafia setups. You-Solve-It was a bit too hardcore for me.
C’mon, let’s hang someone!
Of course, we could get lucky and set the record for Shortest Mafia Game Ever. 
Is that even possible? It’s my understanding that our GM kills one of us at random if we refuse to decide.
The first time I played this game, I was scum and sloppy and got hanged the first day. I twigged the town’s suspicions and they got lucky. We could too. It’s better I think if our killing is somehow directed.
If “no lynch” has the majority there will be no lynch. I want to take my 4% chance of instant win though.
How awesome would that be! Maybe we could even get the game to stay under 10 pages in length! 
But coolness aside, I am not sure it is a good idea to try.
Ya know…there is the possibility that you have a very good reason to feel that way… :dubious:
Wow, no official start and we’ve begun already
I’m wondering just how the hell can we peg someone as a boss on day one…err, should I start this, or really should we wait for the go flag?
Oooh, the game hasn’t even started yet, and :: sniff, sniff :: is that blood I smell?
This is the first, and probably last, time you’ll ever hear me say this, but I think No Lynch is the best bet for Today. I believe scum are going to try to recruit Tonight, to keep from having an instaloss, if you will. Hopefully, we’ll wake up Tomorrow with double the chance of catching Mafia, and there won’t be anybody dead. (Which is kind of why a Night start would have made more sense, game-play wise.) If we can create it artificially, I see no reason why we shouldn’t.
Vote: No lynch.
I was going to wait for the official start, but **Rugger ** said what I was going to say.
It’s not worth it.
- An insta-win is lame. I want to win legitimately.
- A No Lynch costs us nothing.
- The only players that have information about anyone but themselves are the Masons. Thus any slip of extra information is going to hurt the Town.
- There’s a 96% chance we’ll lynch a Townie. Why give the Mafia a freebie?
- There’s large chance we’ll focus on a power role and force a claim a Day One. It’s a risk we can avoid.
A No Lynch is the only rational course for Day One.
Heck, can we vote now?
Vote No Lynch
Whoa, we are getting ahead of ourselves. The Day hasn’t started yet!
I doubt this would be a problem since each Day/Night is a full week. As long as you think you can manage, I have no problem.
I say - I’m not down as a player! :eek:
I would be prepared to be a sub, if there are no places left.
I support the no-lynch plan, (though I’m unclear if we’re supposed to be voting in blue yet.)