making home made bread

So, ever since I’ve binge watched Michael Pollan’s Netflix foodie series (name escapes me right now) I have been curious about making home made bread…

So, could I make bread with simply water, flour and a pinch of salt? Could I leave that mixture laying around for a few hours/days (?) and have home-made sourdough? Is there any danger in this? Am going to get food poison?

Also, does it matter that you never really open your windows and your house is air conditioned (almost year round- I live in Florida)??

Just curious to hear from any bread making experts out there…

I’m not an expert, but I’ve made many a loaf (and pizza crust) just using white flour, water, a bit of oil, and a package of yeast. I usually use maybe one third whole wheat four, too, just to give it some flavor.

it’s a crapshoot. You have no idea what’s floating in the air. You might discover Florida Sourdough and make everyone forget San Francisco or you might ruin a bunch or flour and water.

It’s more reliable to buy a starter and follow directions.

Most bread has leavening and some fat. Your recipe has neither, which would make it a rather bland flatbread.

Yeah, classic French bread is solely flour, water, salt, and yeast. It’s fun to make and everyone should try it.

In NYC fabulous bread is easily available all over the place, so I hardly ever make homemade bread. Focaccia once in a while, or something weird like a cheese-red pepper bread.

If I was in Florida I’d put the bread dough outside on the deck/patio/backyard to rise in the warm, humid air.

I’ve been making my own bread since 2004. Mine is very simple:

Water, sugar, maple syrup, honey, salt, olive oil, yeast and flour.

The sugar serves as food for the yeast so that it rises properly. The finished bread is not sweet.

Home bread baker here for decades.

Yes, you can make excellent bread with only water, flour and salt. It takes some time, however. You’ll need to catch yeast organisms from the air and make a sourdough starter. Then you need to give it some time to grow and ferment. Don’t add salt until you’re ready to make a loaf. It retards the yeast growth.

Sourdough bread is lovely, but it is not fast. If you want additional instruction on how to get a good starter going, feel free to PM me and I’ll send you more information on how to do it. Maintaining a good starter once you’ve got it going can be a bit of a pain and you do need to use it a lot.

You won’t get food poisoning, but if you decide to catch some wild yeast to make your bread, I urge you to cover your flour/water mixture with a cloth. It will help keep bacteria from tainting your mixture. When the sourdough is working as it should, it will have a pleasant beery smell to it and will bubble readily when more flour is added.

I’m not an expert, by any means, but I have baked many a loaf of bread and done some experimentation. I think I can make a solid recommendation that you start with just making bread in the most straightforward way possible, and do that enough times that it’s not a big deal to up and decide you’d like fresh bread today. I know people are generally inspired to try breadmaking because they have something fancy in mind, but I don’t think it’s ever a good idea in any art or craft to skip learning to grind through the basic stuff until you can do them automatically.

I started by working with a book called Ratio, which I may have seen recommended here on the Straight Dope. It deals with how many recipes at the fundamental level involve ratios among basic ingredients. From there you can get as complicated as you want.

Basic Ingredients: Basically bread is 5 parts flour to 3 parts liquid by weight. But you also need salt (which is generally recommend as 1% of the weight of the flour) – multiple sources will tell you it’s because it just won’t taste right otherwise, but I think the sources that say that the salt is needed to moderate the growth of the yeast are more on point. But, yeah, you’ll notice something off if the salt is missing. =)

Basic Technique: Motherfuckers will tell you that you need to knead the dough until you can stretch it to near translucency without it breaking. Those motherfuckers are involved in cruel conspiracy. Oh, it’s possible, but as you’ll learn later, different styles of bread ask for different dough consistencies, and most of these ranges produce something you’ll be glad to jam in your face. There are even recipes in which you just leave the stuff alone and a good enough gluten network forms its own damned self. Also, go ahead and screw around hand kneading just let the nature of the dough make an impression on your mind, but invest in a stand mixer with dough hooks as soon as possible.

Yeast: I entirely skipped all this business with buying yeast in packets. My grocery store sold it by the jar, and it was cheaper. I don’t proof yeast, I just let it sit on top of the water I’ll be mixing in for a few minutes while I do something else - which technique was recommended to me when I used to homebrew, because the yeast wakes up in the water, and has oxygen from the air to get it fired up. However, now I only use Saf-Instant yeast that I buy online, putting some in a yeast jar and freezing the rest. It is made not to need proofing or other preparation. Just throw it in.

Moving on: As delicious as bread is with just that crap, you want to start throwing in some source of fat as soon as possible. Usually butter. It’s tasty. But the main reason I recommend it is that it creates a different texture. Your bubbles will be smaller, making it more versatile for applications other than just tearing it in chunks and jamming it in your mouth.

Right. So do that a bunch of times until it doesn’t seem nearly so laborious, then start planning all those tricky bread styles with exacting ratios and techniques.

There are also multiple recipes for unleavened breads that can be made with just flour and water, with no yeast at all. They’re mostly only eaten for religious purposes, because without even salt, it’s not going to be very palatable, but it can be done.

In many parts of the world, if you just leave your flour and water out and wait, you’ll grow mold, not yeast.