[QUOTE=Sal Ammoniac]
Well, if you’re going to have a universal care system, someone has to pay for it, and whether it’s individuals or businesses is really the same to me. Of course, if individuals are to pay, then they’ll need higher wages, so it comes to the same for business. Here’s what I think is the best solution, just because it takes advantage of many features of the existing system: let everyone in the state of Massachusetts choose an HMO, and fund the whole thing out of payroll taxes. Have a sliding scale such that small businesses only pay a portion of the levy. If you’re a one-man band, you’d pay 10% of the levy, let’s say. Call it $500 annually.
The fact is, most bigger business are already paying for healthcare for their employees. By letting them pay a simple tax per employee to the state, they would get entirely out of the business of administering health plans and negotiating with the HMOs, not to mention their unions. That represents big savings for business. And the administrative efficiency of having a single payer (the state), would probably mean you could insure everybody in the state without adding a single dollar beyond what we’re already paying. The HMOs would act as intermediaries, enrolling individuals, negotiating rates with hospitals, and paying claims – in other words, doing what they do now, only with vastly greater efficiency, because they wouldn’t have to negotiate separate deals with thousands of different parties.
And with vastly increased efficiency on the payor side, you could then devote some attention to finding efficiencies in coding, billing, information technology, medical practice, etc.
So that’s my plan. And I consider it a pro-business plan, because business would save money overall, and have a (slightly) more motivated workforce. Plus you’d see more innovation and entrepreneurship. There are probably lots of people who’d strike out on their own, but who are afraid of the costs of providing their own coverage, particularly if they have families.
[/QUOTE]
What about co-pays, limits on benefits, deductibles and prescriptions?
Presently my employer offers a great health plan. It doesn’t cost all that much (the company pays a lot towards the insurance) and has low co-pays and deductibles, high limits and cheap perscriptions. Do all the copays go away? What about limits and perscriptions? Do deductibles go away?
I highly doubt that a government plan would cost the same as or less than what I have now and offer the same quality coverage. I know that many people are in the same place that I am. (The last two companies I worked for had great insurance plans, one of those business employed thousands of people)
Also, how do you stop government program bloat? Government programs tend to expand over time and get big and inefficient.
Slee