Splanky
December 8, 2004, 3:06am
21
After some algebra, I worked out that there are 6 possible polynomials for which
f(f(x)) = g(x) is true
f(x) = ±x^2 -2x +c
c can be any 3 of the solutions to to c^3 -8c^2 + c - 2 = 0
(All three solutions to this polynomial are real)
Then again, that’s only polynomials. Lord knows how to show that there are/aren’t non-polynomial solutions.
A little more searching turned up this page , which has a whole lot of references on the topic.
Splanky
December 8, 2004, 3:12am
23
Actually, I’m tired, and I’ve lost track of my work. I thought my polynomial had three distinct zeros, but I just checked and the one in my previous post doesn’t (only one real zero). Unless I’m making another mistake there are only 2 polynomials for f(x).
Depends. Are we working in R [symbol]®[/symbol] R or C [symbol]®[/symbol] C ?
Splanky
December 8, 2004, 3:24am
25
Well I’m assuming we’re not dealing with complex solutions.
Anyway, I looked over my work and I think I caught my mistake. (Maybe someone could check my work for me).
If you take MikeS’s work and set the coefficients of the two polynomials equal to each other, you get this system:
a^2 = 1
2*a^2 * b = -4
a(2ac +b^2 +b) = 8
c(b + ac +1) =2
I get that b = -2 (always)
a = -1 or 1
-c^3 +16c^2 - c = 2
^This is the right polynomial, I think. It DOES have 3 real solutions.
nivlac
December 8, 2004, 4:28am
26
f(x) = x[sup]2[/sup] - 2x -1 works. Just a little intelligent trial and error. Don’t believe there’s a general solution approach.