Melting wood

In his article about why wood won’t melt:

Cecil wrote that if you heat wood in vacuum you would get liquefied carbon.

I say it depends. Tar is made by heating conifer wood in a pile that wont let oxygen in. So I’d say that tar is liquefied wood.

pine tar is a liquid at a certain temperature and comes from wood.

melting is a physical change of state. water, metal both exist is a frozen and liquid state. only heat transfer is needed. the substance is unchanged in the transformation.

pine tar is a chemical change. you can’t make it go back into a tree form by changing its heat content.

it is correct to say pine tar is a liquid derived from wood. it is not correct to say it is liquefied wood in the melting sense.

Cecil is the brain.

Because wood is a complex structure, outgassing is going to change that structure. So you will never be able to refreeze the “liquified wood” of liquid carbon.