The White Sox haven’t done much better without La Russa and with him, but maybe it was too late for a change to make any difference.
Let’s have a look at the managers shitcanned in 2022 and how their replacements are doing!
Phillies - Fired Joe Girardi (22-29) hired Rob Thomson (61-39)
The very definition of a management change helping. Thomson, when the Phillies visited Toronto, became the first Canadian manager to manage an MLB game in Canada. The Phillies haven’t made the playoffs in ten years and the Thomson move might get them there. If they do he’ll likely win Manager of the Year.
Blue Jays - Fired Charlie Montoyo (46-42) for John Schneider (39-25)
Montoyo is the only manager in this list shitcanned when his team was over .500. Not as dramatic an improvement as the Phillies, but still a really big one that appears set to put them in the playoffs. Schneider was drafted as a player by the Jays in 2002 and has worked for them ever since; almost all the team-developed players they have had been managed by Schneider in the minors at some point. By all accounts, no one in the clubhouse had a problem with the change.
Rangers - Fired Chris Woodward (51-63) for Tony Beasley (14-23)
I didn’t think the Rangers had high expectations for this year anyway and they were playing better than they did in 2021 so this surprised me. I know they spend half a billion dollars on the middle infield, but Woodward didn’t have a lot of pitching to work with. Anyway they’re not playing better with Beasley.
Angels - Fired Joe Maddon (27-29) for Phil Nevin (39-57)
Ouch. The Maddon firing, it should be noted, wasn’t exactly for being 27-29, but for starting the year 27-17 and then losing twelve in a row. Obviously, things have not gone better. Given Maddon’s track record and the Angels being a disaster, I am inclined to believe firing him wasn’t some sort of well calculated move.
The Angels are such a bizarre tire fire of a franchise that I really have no idea what to tell you about Phil Nevin or if this firing made sense or not. It’s Ohtani, Trout, and a cast of apparent losers, and an owner everyone hates. Has any team EVER had two talents of such rare greatness and been this terrible, year after year?
So kind of a mixed bag of results.