moi: BIG FISH -or- little fish?

Some folx bring the Teeming Millions their 'puter problems, some their child challenges or dating dilemmas. I present to you: <drum roll, please!> moi’s career conundrum.

I currently have two job offers on my plate, doing very different things and with very different workloads, responsibilities, challenges, etc. Summarized, they are:

Job A
Graphic and Web site design for my alma mater. I would be working with the head of data/information to create graphic interpretations of key university data and designing and maintaining an outlet for this information on the Web.
This is an 11-month contract that is worth $10,000 more than my current salary, no benefits.
I have about 6 mos. of previous Web design and would like to learn more and to have more of my product “out there.” I’m not going to “grow up and be a Web designer,” but I consider it a useful skill.
I have worked with this woman in the past and get along famously with her. I understand her lingo and her priorities and am successful at creating those things visually.

Job B
The director of the small museum where I currently work is resigning. The interim directorship has been offered to me…basically, this is the craziest promotion I will ever get. I would be responsible for the day-to-day operations of the museum and maintaining the current exhibition schedule, as well as filling in some of our exhibition gaps. I would coordinate all museum events, including our major fundraiser in September, all openings and lectures, and all catalogue materials and continue my job of producing the museum newsletter. I would also maintain the museum Web site.
Because the museum has fallen on hard times financially, I would attempt to maintain the current level of quality, while reducing some of the quantity of what we do, thus getting some idea of how non-profits are run ('cos, well, very few have an excess of money to do their work with). I might also learn a few things about grant-writing along the way.
Part of this offer includes the opportunity for me to work alongside professional registrars (either in Pittsburgh or New York) in order to pick up that skill set and use it in tackling our permanent collection.
After a permanent director is appointed, I would either return to my status as a freelancer producing their newsletter or be written a position as the museum registrar (depending on what I had learned and accomplished thus far).
There’s no time frame to this job…I could have it for 5 months, I could have it for 2 years (the last director search took 18 months). My current salary would increase by approximately $15,000, plus benefits.
This is basically the kind of work that I want to do, I just feel very unprepared for it now. The current financial situation of the museum is also a worry; as cat said, it’s like being told the ship is going down and you’ve just been promoted to captain. <wry grin>

A wee bit about me
I’m a recent college graduate (major: journalism, minor: art history), 23 y.o. and “generically” plan on returning to grad school (for art history or art management) September 2002. After my master’s, I’d like to work in museums, either in publications or development, but eventually working as a curator or a museum director.

Thus far, I’ve been very drawn in by the security of Job A. It’s been offered to me and is just waiting to hear from me. Job B has involved a lot of commotion in my life already and involves negotiating with the dean of fine arts for my job description and what I’m worth. Also, once I get into the job, it’s not like there’s any security for me (once they hire a director, I’m fini) or any long-term reward (I can’t be promoted or kept as director). However, in terms of resume and experience, it makes my eyebrows waggle.

Odieman summarized it as a choice of responsibility–between being a child (Job A) and an adult (Job B). My fiancé says it’s the choice between being a little fish (Job A) and a big fish (Job B).

What say you? Any advice? Any ideas relevant to either job? Suggestions? Questions? Topic for further consideration? I have until June 15th to figure it all out.

–And thanks in advance for anything y’all can offer. My peer group IRL is all 20-somethings in their first jobs, supportive, but limited in experience. Hence my calling out upon your collective wisdom and experience. Again, danke. :smiley:

Gird your loins and follow your joy. Sometimes you have to take a job to get the preparation you need to have the job.

Good luck, moi!

From everything in your post, I’d have to recommend you jump all over job B. Many of those positions have the old catch-22; you can’t get the experience without the job and you can’t get the job without the experience. This is your best chance through that door. If it lasts for at least six months, it should help in opening some other doors for you. I’d put “director” on future resumes, not “interim director.” You will be the director, in job function, after all.

You state that you can’t be kept as a director. Is this the case even if you perform the job flawlessly?

This utterly <boinked> me on the head, DMC. This is an excellent point, and I hadn’t thought of it this way yet. Thank you! :slight_smile:
As to your other query, the institution is required to have an official search for the director and come up with more than one candidate. Since I don’t yet have my master’s, there’s really no way for me to compete, even if I have a year’s worth of experience as interim.

Knead, I want you to know that if I go with Job B, I’m gonna print out the advice “Gird your loins and follow your joy” to go next to my desk. Thank you!

[sub]Um, hey, you guys. Yeah, the other 70-or-so of ya who read this thread. Any advice for li’l ole moi?[/sub]

You’re welcome. Be sure to let us all know what you decide.

Well, okay. I’d say job B also, for the same reason as DMC above.

I also think it sucks that no matter how well you’d do at the job, you wouldn’t be considered for the permanent position simply because you don’t have a masters degree.
That is so anally ignorant on their part. But that’s probably fodder for a different thread.

Go with your heart!! Go for Job B!! Don’t assume that just because you don’t have a master’s you have no hope. If you do a bang-up job (as you certainly will) and make some higher-ups look good, that’ll carry a whole lot of weight. Also, you may find out that being the big fish isn’t for you, in which case you can add the experience to your resume and move on to kick ass elswhere.

On a more pragmatic note, benefits, especially medical insurance, are a good thing.

I think Job B sounds interesting. While it may not be a permanent position, it will look damn good on a resume. It sounds like a great opportunity, and they wouldn’t have offered it to you if they thought you couldn’t handle it. I say go for it. :slight_smile: You can always be a web designer.

Rose

No doubt about it. Job B.

Had a similar choice last summer. Job B equivalent’s first assignment: Move the sub indoors. Didn’t get an offer, so taking present job was a Good Idea, but I still wonder.

I can hijack my own thread, right? <angelic smilie here>

Um, dropzone…As in a submarine? :eek:

Job Update: I’ve sent in a job description and salary requirement for Job B. I should hear back sometime tomorrow…

Yup. The job was Project Manager at a prominent Chicago museum. Their u-boat is returning to its constituent ores, so they’re going to build a building for it. Which will involve lifting and moving it about a block.

Me: “Good thing it was built so strong in the first place!”

Interviewer: “Yeah, but I wouldn’t stand under its stern after they lift it.”

Looked like fun, but a) didn’t get the offer, and b) would have been a pain of a job. But you’re young. Go for it.

Dropzone, That’d be the Museum of Science and Industry, IIRC. I visited that place over 40 years ago and remember that submarine. Do they still have that gigantic train layout inside? Mrs. B and I have been planning a few days in Chicago some time soon, and if it’s still there, I’ll put it on the itinerary. I’d sure like to see that again.

Sorry for the hijack Moi, good luck on the job.

Um, I was trying NOT to name names. Even of POTENTIAL employers. Even though my description narrowed the possibilities to one. :wink:

I think they still have the trains. A lot of people love that one. They don’t have any of the ones I worked on when in the exhibit biz.

One of the lessons I didn’t learn in college: the day you feel prepared for life is the day life has nothing more to offer you.

I’d say go for job B. It’s the field you’re interested in, it will look fantastic on your resume, and it’s the chance to show a lot of people just what you’re capable of. On top of everything else, the pay looks great, too!

The only downside is that you say you don’t feel ready. Well, consider that the people who offered you the job know who you are, how old you are, and how much experience you have, and they apparently think you’re ready enough.

Whichever you choose, good luck!

WARNING: PWI (posting while intoxicated). Take all advice contained in this post with a grain of salt. Then add it to your margarita. They really mix!

–sublight.

“Look, the worst you can do is burn the place to the ground. Anything else can go in the plus column.”

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by dropzone *
Um, I was trying NOT to name names. Even of POTENTIAL employers. Even though my description narrowed the possibilities to one. :wink:

[QUOTE]

Errrr…sorry. :o

Since you’ve already sent in your info, this is kinda pointless, but I’d go for option B, too. Think of it this way, the next time you might hav ethis opportunity would be years from now, right? Graphic design jobs is everywhere, museum director positions, however fleeting, are not.

Good luck, wish you the best, moi.

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by Sublight *
**

This is an excellent point. If for some reason things don’t work out with Job B and it ends up being only a 5 month deal, you will always have other Job A-type offers (and you are young enough to be able to shop around for them with relative time-frame freedom).

Spend some time going over what you feel confident you do well at work. Don’t doubt yourself or your abilities, and don’t doubt what your co-workers seem to think.

I say definitely go with Job B. Keep us posted!

Thank you, Winkie, Rose, dropzone, Sublight, thinksnow and Pucette! Hearin’ y’all’s opnions is definitely helping set my resolve for this week’s negotiations.

Tonight, my job description goes to the museum’s executive board. Now I just have to start thinking about how low I’m willing to go (in terms of salary) before callin’ the negotiations quits and headin’ out for Job A. Mucho intimidating. :eek:
checks watch Guess it’s too early for that margarita…

Actually, nothing is decided yet. Job A is still on the burner, and I don’t have a coherent offer from Job B yet. Part of my frustration is that I have two weeks of vacation coming up, and I’d like to have my future employment sorted by then. But I might be setting an unreasonable deadline for the museum.

Hallelujiah, yes! :slight_smile: I’ve spent the last year technically being a freelancer and would love to be back under the wing of employer-provided benefits again.

[list][li] Don’t doubt yourself or your abilities, and don’t doubt what your co-workers seem to think.[/li][snip]
[li] If you do a bang-up job (as you certainly will)…[/li][snip]
[li] …you can add the experience to your resume and move on to kick ass elswhere.[/li]
Thanks for bein’ so good for the moi ego, everyone. :smiley: