This is really innovative. I wonder if anyone had tried it.
In my experience, the best way to deal with AOL support is to call during non-business hours. As I understand it, during business hours their support lines are manned by marketing people whose goal is to keep you as a customer. They will try to negotiate with you to stop you from disconnecting AOL. But during evenings or weekends, you’ll be talking to people in technical support - their goal is to solve whatever the customer’s complaint is in the quickest and easiest fashion. So if you call a technical person and tell them you want your AOL service disconnected, they’ll flip a switch and turn it off and ask you if that solves your problem. You say yes and they move on to the next call.