Movies that right up until the last 10 minutes had you going..."Nooo.This isn't really happening."

[Morbo]

@Frylock

I didn’t really like the film overall, but I don’t have any particular problem with there being aliens in it at the end. Why is that bad?

I guess I was OK with the world being mystical and like a fantasy with religious artifacts and whatnot, but switching over to Sci-Fi with Aliens seemed way wrong to me. Plus, compared with the weight of the kinds of stories surrounding the Bible, (Ark, Holy Grail), having them look for Crystal Skulls was weak sauce. Why not just have him find Santa Claus or Big Foot?

Also, if the movie was really good up to that point and had earned the aliens I might have been more OK with it - but I had reached my breaking point by then based on the shit sandwich I had put up with already.

[RikWriter]

@Snowboarder_Bo

No, the OP doesn’t say that.

“Meaning, movies that you kept waiting for the penny to drop…but pretty much either the title said it all or they played it straight and it’s your own skepticism that kept you from believing.”

That doesn’t describe Frailty. Everyone in the movie other than the dad and younger brother were skeptical. The supposed narrator, the POV character, was skeptical. Then there was a twist. That’s not what the OP was describing.