All Quiet on the Western Front, 2022 (Netflix).
Definitely worth seeing, especially for Remarque fans and WW1 buffs.
I think one of the hardest things a movie especially historical movies, have to portray is mental unpreparedness (is that a word?) Too many times, movie characters act as if they’ve seen this movie before. Which is OK if it’s Ticket to Paradise or other popcorn/date films.
But imagine going to the Western Front in 1915, having never, ever, seen a war movie. Which, of course, was the case… for the soldiers, the generals, the civilians… man, no wonder psychological health came to the fore in WW1. Take a man from a farm, where he has lived in a 5 mile radius his entire life, and throw him into the mechanized hell of Verdun… no wonder the thousand-yard stare became a thing.
This film did pretty good at showing this. Of course, it follows educated teenagers so the shift wasn’t as large as described above, and, of course, Remarque was more interested in other themes, but this film didn’t ignore the mental strains of just the insanity of it all. But for some reason, this movie triggered in me some wonderment about what it would be like to go to Flanders fields or Verdun or the Somme having zero comprehension about what you’re headed into.
On the other hand, the movie failed where most, if not all movies fail: the depiction of odors. You walk into a room of dead bodies, you’re covering your damned noses, people. Amazes me how many times obviously smelly situations are just ignored - crack houses stink! Murder scenes smell! And rooms full of gassed, dead soldiers are f-in odorous!
Fucking-A, at least wrinkle your noses, guys. That’s why they call it acting!
Anyway, feeling generous, will give it 4.5 stars of 5.