Muppet Madness (Round One) -- Who is the Dope's most beloved Muppet?

Jim Henson Division

  1. Kermit the Frog
  2. Grover
  3. Elmo
  4. The Swedish Chef
  5. Aloysius Snuffleupagus
  6. Dr. Teeth
  7. Crazy Harry
  8. Rizzo the Rat

Frank Oz Division

  1. Cookie Monster
  2. Ernie
  3. Oscar the Grouch
  4. Gonzo
  5. Sherlock Hemlock
  6. Roosevelt Franklin
  7. The Newsman
  8. Floyd Pepper

Dave Goelz Division

  1. Big Bird
  2. Count von Count
  3. Fozzy Bear
  4. Statler and Waldorf
  5. Scooter - this one was hard; I like Biff & Sully
  6. Janice
  7. Guy Smiley
  8. Robin the Frog

Richard Hunt Division

  1. Miss Piggy
  2. Bert
  3. Sam the Eagle
  4. Dr. Bunson Honeydew
  5. Rowlf
  6. The Yip-Yips - this one was really hard!
  7. Herry Monster
  8. Sweetums

Jim Henson Division

  1. Kermit the Frog

  2. Grover

  3. Elmo

  4. The Swedish Chef

  5. Aloysius Snuffleupagus

  6. Dr. Teeth

  7. Crazy Harry

  8. Rizzo the Rat (One of my favorites, always had a funny line)
    Frank Oz Division

  9. Cookie Monster

  10. Ernie

  11. Oscar the Grouch

  12. Gonzo

  13. Animal

  14. Beaker

  15. Zoe (giving the benefit to Muppis I’ve heard of even if I didn’t like them and Zoe bugged me)

8.Camilla the Chicken (Gonzo’s girlfriend!)
Dave Goelz Division

  1. Big Bird

  2. Count von Count

  3. Fozzy Bear

  4. Statler and Waldorf

  5. Scooter

  6. Wanda

  7. Guy Smiley

  8. Telly Monster (Telly was great, Robin was an annoying version of Kermit)

Richard Hunt Division

  1. Miss Piggy

  2. Bert

  3. Sam the Eagle

  4. Dr. Bunson Honeydew

  5. Rowlf

  6. The Yip-Yips

  7. Gladys the Cow

  8. Sweetums

  1. Kermit the Frog
  2. Grover
  3. Elmo
  4. The Swedish Chef
  5. Aloysius Snuffleupagus
  6. Dr. Teeth
  7. Crazy Harry
  8. Rizzo the Rat

Frank Oz Division

  1. Cookie Monster
  2. Ernie
  3. Oscar the Grouch
  4. Gonzo
  5. Animal
  6. Beaker
  7. Zoe
  8. Floyd Pepper

Dave Goelz Division

  1. Big Bird
  2. Count von Count
  3. Fozzy Bear
  4. Statler and Waldorf
  5. Scooter
  6. Wanda
  7. Guy Smiley
  8. Telly Monster

Richard Hunt Division

  1. Miss Piggy
  2. Bert
  3. Sam the Eagle
  4. Dr. Bunson Honeydew
  5. Rowlf
  6. Mahna Mahna
  7. Gladys the Cow
  8. Sweetums

Jim Henson

  1. Kermit
  2. Grover
  3. Elmo
  4. Swedish Chef
  5. Marvin Suggs (and his amazing Muppa-Phone)
    6 - 11 Tie (it is too cruel to have to choose)
  6. Crazy Harry
    8 Rizzo

Frank Oz

  1. COOKIE
  2. Ernie
  3. oscar
  4. Gonzo
  5. Animal
  6. Beaker
    10 The Newsman
  7. Floyd

Dave Golez

  1. Big Bird
  2. Count Von Count
  3. Fozzy
  4. Statler and Waldorf
  5. Scooter
  6. Janice
  7. Guy Smiley
  8. Robin

Richard Hunt

  1. Miss Piggy
  2. Bert
  3. Sam the AMERICAN eagle
  4. Dr. Bunson Honeydew
  5. Rowlf
  6. yip-yips
  7. Herry monster
  8. Sweetums

Jim Henson Division

  1. Kermit the Frog

  2. Lefty the Salesman

  3. Wayne

  4. Forgetful Jones

  5. Aloysius Snuffleupagus

  6. Dr. Teeth

  7. Gorgon Heap

  8. Lew Zealand
    Frank Oz Division

  9. Cookie Monster

  10. Ernie

  11. Oscar the Grouch

  12. Buster the Horse

  13. Sherlock Hemlock

  14. Roosevelt Franklin

  15. The Newsman

  16. Floyd Pepper
    Dave Goelz Division

  17. Baskerville the Hound

  18. Count von Count

  19. Fozzy Bear

  20. Statler and Waldorf

  21. Scooter

  22. Janice

  23. Guy Smiley

  24. Robin the Frog
    Richard Hunt Division

  25. Winky Pinkerton

  26. Bert

  27. Sam the Eagle

  28. Dr. Bunson Honeydew

  29. Rowlf

  30. Mahna Mahna

  31. Gladys the Cow

  32. Zoot

Jim Henson Division

  1. Kermit the Frog
  2. Grover
  3. Wayne (anti-Elmo vote!)
  4. The Swedish Chef
  5. Dr. Teeth
  6. Gorgon Heap

Frank Oz Division

  1. Cookie Monster
  2. Ernie
  3. Oscar the Grouch
  4. Gonzo
  5. Animal
  6. Beaker
  7. The Newsman
  8. Floyd Pepper

Dave Goelz Division

  1. Big Bird
  2. Count von Count
  3. Fozzy Bear
  4. Statler and Waldorf
  5. Scooter
  6. Wanda
  7. Telly Monster

Richard Hunt Division

  1. Miss Piggy
  2. Bert
  3. Sam the Eagle
  4. Dr. Bunson Honeydew
  5. Rowlf
  6. Mahna Mahna YES!
  7. Sweetums

[Jim Henson Division

  1. Kermit the Frog
  2. Grover
  3. Wayne
  4. The Swedish Chef
  5. Aloysius Snuffleupagus
  6. Dr. Teeth
  7. Gorgon Heap
  8. Rizzo the Rat
    Frank Oz Division
  9. Cookie Monster
  10. Ernie
  11. Oscar the Grouch
  12. Gonzo
  13. Animal
  14. Beaker
  15. The Newsman
  16. Floyd Pepper
    Dave Goelz Division
  17. Big Bird
  18. Count von Count
    this was harder than expected
  19. Fozzy Bear
  20. Statler and Waldorf
  21. Scooter
  22. Wanda
  23. The Amazing Mumford
    toughest choice
  24. Telly Monster

Richard Hunt Division

  1. Miss Piggy
  2. Bert
  3. Sam the Eagle
  4. Dr. Bunson Honeydew
  5. Rowlf
    10.Gladys the Cow
    9.Zoot

My only question is: How come Statler and Waldorf are one entry whereas Wayne and Wanda, who are also always seen together, are two? I think the brackets have been tampered with by a certain American eagle who’s attempting to have a sophisticated performer win over all the weirdos.

Anyway…it’s time to play the music, it’s time to light the lights, it’s time to give my choices in the Muppet game tonight:

Jim Henson Division

  1. Kermit the Frog
  2. Grover
  3. Elmo
  4. The Swedish Chef
  5. Marvin Suggs
  6. Link Hogthrob
  7. Crazy Harry
  8. Lew Zealand

Frank Oz Division

  1. Cookie Monster
  2. Ernie
  3. Oscar the Grouch
  4. Gonzo
  5. Animal
  6. Beaker
  7. The Newsman
  8. Floyd Pepper

Dave Goelz Division

  1. Big Bird
  2. Count von Count
  3. Fozzie Bear
  4. Statler and Waldorf
  5. Scooter
  6. Janice
  7. Guy Smiley
  8. Telly Monster

Richard Hunt Division

  1. Miss Piggy
  2. Bert
  3. Sam the Eagle
  4. Dr. Bunsen Honeydew
  5. Rowlf
  6. The Yip-Yips
  7. Herry Monster
  8. Sweetums
    Good idea for a game- I love Muppets! (Who doesn’t?) Lots of tough matchups here, but some shoo-ins as well.

The answer is: I’m arbitrary and capricious. And I didn’t think it through enough, I guess. Also, by the time I was poking around for the final dozen or so muppets, I was scraping near the bottom of the barrel. Splitting up Wayne and Wanda meant I didn’t have to figure out who the 65th most prominent muppet was.

And I just couldn’t bring myself to split up Statler and Waldorf.

Oh, and while I’m here: I forgot to set a deadline for Round One. I’ll say the end of the week – midnight on the 4th of July.

  1. Kermit the Frog

  2. Grover

  3. Wayne

  4. The Swedish Chef

  5. Aloysius Snuffleupagus

  6. Dr. Teeth

  7. Crazy Harry

  8. Rizzo the Rat
    Frank Oz Division

  9. Cookie Monster

  10. Ernie

  11. The Snowths

  12. Gonzo

  13. Animal

  14. Beaker

  15. The Newsman

  16. Camilla the Chicken

Dave Goelz Division

  1. Big Bird
  2. Count von Count
  3. Fozzy Bear
  4. Statler and Waldorf
  5. Biff & Sully
  6. Janice
  7. The Amazing Mumford
  8. Robin the Frog

Richard Hunt Division

  1. Miss Piggy
  2. Bert
  3. Sam the Eagle
  4. Dr. Bunson Honeydew
  5. Uncle Deadly - though I think I’m fighting a lost cause
  6. Mahna Mahna - hardest choice on here
  7. Herry Monster
  8. Sweetums

Jim Henson Division

  1. Kermit the Frog
  2. Grover
  3. Elmo
  4. The Swedish Chef
  5. Aloysius Snuffleupagus
  6. Dr. Teeth
  7. Gorgon Heap
  8. Rizzo the Rat

Frank Oz Division

  1. Cookie Monster
  2. Ernie
  3. Oscar the Grouch
  4. Gonzo
  5. Animal
  6. Roosevelt Franklin
  7. The Newsman
  8. Floyd Pepper

Dave Goelz Division

  1. Big Bird

  2. Count von Count

  3. Fozzy Bear

  4. Twiddlebugs

  5. Scooter

  6. Janice

  7. Guy Smiley

  8. Telly Monster
    Richard Hunt Division

  9. Miss Piggy

  10. Bert

  11. Sam the Eagle

  12. Dr. Julius Strangepork

  13. Uncle Deadly

  14. The Yip-Yips

  15. Herry Monster

  16. Zoot

Jim Henson Division

  1. Kermit the Frog

  2. Grover

  3. Wayne (I don’t particularly like Wayne, but I loathe Elmo)

  4. The Swedish Chef (Bork.Bork.Bork)

  5. Aloysius Snuffleupagus

  6. Dr. Teeth

  7. Crazy Harry

  8. Lew Zealand
    Frank Oz Division

  9. Cookie Monster

  10. Ernie

  11. Oscar the Grouch

  12. Gonzo

  13. Animal

  14. Beaker

  15. The Newsman

  16. Floyd Pepper (While I was at UMass I knew a guy who was Floyd)
    Dave Goelz Division

  17. Big Bird

  18. Beauregard

  19. Fozzy Bear

  20. Statler and Waldorf

  21. Scooter

  22. Janice

  23. Guy Smiley

  24. Robin the Frog
    Richard Hunt Division

  25. Miss Piggy

  26. Bert

  27. Sam the Eagle (Isn’t this supposed to be “Sam, the American Eagle”?)

  28. Dr. Bunson Honeydew

  29. Rowlf

  30. Mahna Mahna (this was the hardest match up for me. But I had to got with Mahna Mahna)

  31. Herry Monster

  32. Zoot (“Let’s just get right down to it, and do this little beauty. Forgive me, Charlie Parker, where ever you are.”)

Jim Henson Division

  1. Kermit the Frog

  2. Grover

  3. Wayne

  4. The Swedish Chef

  5. Aloysius Snuffleupagus

  6. Link Hogthrob

  7. Gorgon Heap

  8. Rizzo the Rat

Frank Oz Division

  1. Cookie Monster

  2. Ernie

  3. Oscar the Grouch

  4. Gonzo

  5. Animal

  6. Beaker

  7. Zoe

  8. Camilla the Chicken

Dave Goelz Division

  1. Big Bird

  2. Count von Count

  3. Fozzy Bear

  4. Statler and Waldorf

  5. Biff & Sully

  6. Janice

  7. The Amazing Mumford

  8. Robin the Frog

Richard Hunt Division

  1. Miss Piggy

  2. Bert

  3. Sam the Eagle

  4. Dr. Bunson Honeydew

  5. Rowlf

  6. Mahna Mahna

  7. Herry Monster

vs 9. Zoot

im Henson Division

Kermit the Frog
Grover
Wayne
The Swedish Chef
Marvin Suggs
Dr. Teeth
Gorgon Heap
Lew Zealand

Frank Oz Division

Cookie Monster
Ernie
Oscar the Grouch
Gonzo
Sherlock Hemlock
Beaker
The Newsman
Floyd Pepper

Dave Goelz Division

Big Bird
Count von Count
Fozzy Bear
Statler and Waldorf
Biff & Sully
Janice
Guy Smiley
Telly Monster

Richard Hunt Division

Winky Pinkerton
Bert
Sam the Eagle
Dr. Bunson Honeydew
Rowlf
-pass
-pass
Sweetums

  1. Kermit the Frog

  2. Grover

  3. Elmo

  4. The Swedish Chef

  5. Aloysius Snuffleupagus

  6. Dr. Teeth

  7. Gorgon Heap

  8. Rizzo the Rat

  9. Cookie Monster

  10. Ernie

  11. Oscar the Grouch

  12. Gonzo

  13. Animal

  14. Beaker

  15. The Newsman

  16. Floyd Pepper

  17. Baskerville the Hound

  18. Count von Count

  19. Fozzy Bear

  20. Statler and Waldorf

  21. Biff & Sully

  22. Janice

  23. Guy Smiley

  24. Robin the Frog

  25. Winky Pinkerton

  26. Bert

  27. Sam the Eagle

  28. Dr. Bunson Honeydew

  29. Rowlf

  30. The Yip-Yips

  31. Herry Monster

  32. Sweetums

I’ve already made my choices. I’m just bummed on some of the choices, the ones where I liked both characters. There were others where I didn’t care as much, I wish I could have eliminated them.

Jim Henson Division

  1. Kermit the Frog
  2. Grover (This was a close contest, actually. I always liked Lefty.)
  3. Wayne
  4. The Swedish Chef
  5. Marvin Suggs
  6. Dr. Teeth
  7. Gorgon Heap
  8. Lew Zealand

Frank Oz Division

  1. Cookie Monster
  2. Ernie
  3. Oscar the Grouch
  4. Gonzo
  5. Animal
  6. Beaker
  7. The Newsman
  8. Floyd Pepper

Dave Goelz Division
16. Baskerville the Hound
2. Count von Count
3. Fozzy Bear
4. Statler and Waldorf
5. Scooter
6. Janice
10. The Amazing Mumford
8. Robin the Frog

Richard Hunt Division

  1. Miss Piggy
  2. Bert
  3. Sam the Eagle
  4. Dr. Bunson Honeydew
  5. Rowlf
  6. Mahna Mahna
  7. Gladys the Cow
  8. Sweetums

Jim Henson Division

  1. Kermit the Frog
  2. Grover
  3. Elmo Don’t think he’ll make the Sweet Sixteen, but I’ll give him props in the first round for popularity.
  4. The Swedish Chef
  5. Marvin Suggs Muppaphone; 'nuff said.
  6. Link Hogthrob Toughest choice of the first round. Going with Link because Strangepork lost to Bunsen Honeydew.
  7. Crazy Harry
  8. Lew Zealand An obscure favorite of mine, but he’s not doing well in the voting so far. C’mon, he throws fish and calls Kermit “Mr. The Frog”, how can you not love that?

Frank Oz Division

  1. Cookie Monster

  2. Ernie

  3. Oscar the Grouch

  4. Gonzo

  5. Animal

  6. Beaker

  7. The Newsman

  8. Floyd Pepper
    Dave Goelz Division

  9. Big Bird Like Elmo, not a personal favorite, but he advances against weak competition.

  10. Count von Count

  11. Fozzie Bear

  12. Statler and Waldorf

  13. Scooter

  14. Janice

  15. Guy Smiley

  16. Robin the Frog Gets the nod for his rendition of They Call the Wind Mariah.

Richard Hunt Division

  1. Miss Piggy
  2. Bert
  3. Sam the Eagle
  4. Dr. Bunson Honeydew
  5. Uncle Deadly
  6. Mahna Mahna Easy choice. From the 11th seed, could be the Cinderella of the tournament.
  7. Gladys the Cow
  8. Sweetums

Jim Henson Division

  1. Kermit the Frog
  2. Grover
    14.Wayne
  3. The Swedish Chef
    12.Marvin Suggs
  4. Link Hogthrob
    7.Crazy Harry
  5. Rizzo the Rat

Frank Oz Division

  1. Cookie Monster

  2. Ernie

  3. Oscar the Grouch

  4. Gonzo

  5. Animal

  6. Beaker

  7. The Newsman
    8.Camilla the Chicken
    Dave Goelz Division

  8. Baskerville the Hound

  9. Count von Count

  10. Fozzy Bear

  11. Statler and Waldorf
    12.Biff & Sully

  12. Janice
    10.The_Amazing_Mumford
    8.Robin the Frog
    Richard Hunt Division

  13. Miss Piggy

  14. Bert

  15. Sam the Eagle

  16. Dr. Julius Strangepork

  17. Rowlf

  18. Mahna Mahna

  19. Herry Monster

  20. Sweetums

  1. Statler and Waldorf

bah!