-
Kermit the Frog (Hail to the king, baby)
-
Grover (He beats Crazy Harry just on the merits of “There’s A Monster At The End Of This Book”)
-
Dr. Teeth
-
The Swedish Chef
-
Cookie Monster
-
Ernie
-
Beaker
-
Gonzo (This was a tough one)
-
Robin the Frog (Another tough one)
-
Guy Smiley
-
Fozzie Bear
-
Statler and Waldorf
-
Miss Piggy
-
Herry Monster
-
Sam the Eagle (He could also win on “Titwillow” alone.)
-
Rowlf (This was the toughest because I love Honeydew, but Rowlf beats him. He is one of the best [and oldest] muppets. I loved the “Old Brown Ears” album)
Jim Henson Division
8 Rizzo (sympathy vote for the underrat)
2 Grover
6 Dr Teeth
5 Snuffleupagus
Frank Oz Division
1 Cookie Monster
2 Ernie
6 Beaker
Gonzo vs. Animal? I call it a draw.
Dave Goelz Division
8 Robin
2 Count von Count
3 Fozzie
5 Scooter
Richard Hunt Division
1 Miss Piggy
2 Bert
3 Sam
5 Rowlf
Jim Henson Division
Rizzo the Rat
2. Grover
6. Dr. Teeth
4. The Swedish Chef
Frank Oz Division
- Cookie Monster
- The Newsman
- Beaker
- Gonzo
Dave Goelz Division
- Big Bird
- Guy Smiley
- Fozzie Bear
- Statler and Waldorf
Richard Hunt Division
- Miss Piggy
- Bert
- Mahna Mahna
vs 5. Rowlf
Jim Henson Division
-
Kermit the Frog
-
Grover
-
Dr. Teeth
-
The Swedish Chef
Frank Oz Division
-
Cookie Monster
-
Ernie
-
Oscar the Grouch
-
Gonzo
Dave Goelz Division
-
Big Bird
-
Guy Smiley
-
Fozzie Bear
-
Statler and Waldorf
Richard Hunt Division
-
Zoot
-
Bert
-
Sam the Eagle
-
Rowlf
Jim Henson Division
- Kermit the Frog
- Grover
Dr. Teeth - The Swedish Chef
Frank Oz Division
- Cookie Monster
- Ernie
Beaker
Animal
Dave Goelz Division
- Big Bird
- Count von Count
- Fozzie Bear
- Statler and Waldorf
Richard Hunt Division
- Miss Piggy
- Bert
Mahna Mahna - Dr. Bunson Honeydew
Jim Henson Division
- Kermit the Frog (Oddly enough this is a no-brainer for me. For some reason Rizzo always just grated. He has had some great lines, but they were in spite of the character, not because of him.)
- Crazy Harry (How can sweet and stupid compete with explosions?)
- Dr. Teeth (As one of those who voted against Elmo in the first round, I can’t see how this will surprise anyone.)
- The Swedish Chef (Bork.bork.bork.)
Frank Oz Division
- Cookie Monster
- Ernie
- Oscar the Grouch
- Gonzo
Dave Goelz Division
- Big Bird
- Count von Count
- Fozzie Bear
- Statler and Waldorf
Richard Hunt Division
- Zoot
- Herry Monster
- Mahna Mahna
- Rowlf
-
Kermit the Frog (no surprise there, I guess)
-
Grover (Hello everybodeeeee! Grover gets votes from me based on “The Monster at the End of this Book”)
-
Dr. Teeth (I forgot to mention that I will always anti-Elmo vote)
Aloysius Snuffleupagus
Frank Oz Division
-
Cookie Monster (I’m so happy that I don’t yet have to agonize over a Cookie Monster vs. Animal vote)
-
Ernie
-
Oscar the Grouch
-
Animal (but apparently, I do have to agonize over a Gonzo vs. Animal vote.)
Dave Goelz Division -
Big Bird
-
Guy Smiley
-
Janice (Just about anyone but Elmo would beat Fozzie.)
-
Statler and Waldorf
Richard Hunt Division -
Zoot
-
Herry Monster
-
Sam the Eagle
-
Rowlf (Wow, I voted against Beaker and Bunson in the same round. Bad Kat!)
Jim Henson Division
-
Kermit the Frog
-
The Swedish Chef
Frank Oz Division
-
Cookie Monster
-
Ernie
-
Beaker
-
Animal
Dave Goelz Division
- Big Bird
- Count von Count
- Fozzie Bear
- Statler and Waldorf
Richard Hunt Division
- Zoot
- Bert
- Sam the Eagle
- Dr. Bunson Honeydew
-
Rizzo the Rat
-
Grover
-
Dr. Teeth
-
The Swedish Chef
-
Cookie Monster
-
The Newsman
-
Oscar the Grouch
-
Animal
-
Robin the Frog
-
Guy Smiley
-
Fozzie Bear
-
Statler and Waldorf
-
Miss Piggy
-
Herry Monster
-
Sam the Eagle
-
Dr. Bunson Honeydew
[QUOTE=Parthol]
Jim Henson Division
- Kermit the Frog
- Grover
6.Dr. Teeth - The Swedish Chef
Frank Oz Division
- Cookie Monster
- The Newsman
- Oscar the Grouch
- Animal
Dave Goelz Division
8. Robin the Frog
2. Count von Count
6. Janice
4. Statler and Waldorf
Richard Hunt Division
- Miss Piggy
- Bert
- Sam the Eagle
- Rowlf
Jim Henson Division
-
Kermit the Frog – How can you vote against that!
-
Grover – Well, Monster at the End of This Book is my favorite book!
-
Elmo – Hate me if you want, but we like him at our house.
-
Aloysius Snuffleupagus – Hard hard hard
Frank Oz Division
-
Cookie Monster – LOVE LOVE LOVE
-
Ernie – Sure he can be annoying, but think about some of his songs! The one where he imagines he is all the different things is amazing.
-
Oscar the Grouch – We enjoy him a lot here.
-
Gonzo – I love him!
Dave Goelz Division
-
Big Bird
-
Guy Smiley – Hard, because I like the Count, but I just have a soft spot for Guy Smiley.
-
Fozzie Bear
-
Statler and Waldorf – Have to vote for them, but I do love Scooter.
Richard Hunt Division
-
Zoot – Hate Miss Piggy, and wouldn’t even care who Zoot was (but since I’ve voted against Electric Mayhem so much, I’m glad to vote for him)
-
Bert – I feel so sorry for him. All he wants is to read, and play with Bernice, and count his bottle caps, and SLEEP!
-
Mahna Mahna
vs 5. Rowlf
I was gonna keep voting for Waldorf & Statler and screw the rest of the muppets, but now that the matchups are getting more interesting, I’m gonna start voting seriously.
- Rizzo the Rat
vs 7. Crazy Harry
-
Dr. Teeth
-
The Swedish Chef
-
Cookie Monster
vs 10. The Newsman -
Oscar the Grouch
vs 5. Animal (jesus man…TOUGH TOUGH choice, but I gotta go with the muppet inspired by Keith Moon!)
Dave Goelz Division
- Big Bird vs 8. Robin the Frog (I abstain - two of the most annoying muppets ever?)
- Count von Count
vs 6. Janice - Statler and Waldorf (FTW!)
vs 9. Zoot
2. Bert
3. Sam the Eagle
- Dr. Bunson Honeydew (another really tough one - science or music?)
Jim Henson Division
- Kermit the Frog
- Grover
- Dr. Teeth
- The Swedish Chef
Frank Oz Division
- Cookie Monster
- The Newsman
- Oscar the Grouch
- Gonzo
Dave Goelz Division
- Big Bird
- Count von Count
- Fozzie Bear
- Statler and Waldorf
Richard Hunt Division
- Miss Piggy
- Herry Monster
- Sam the Eagle
- Rowlf
Now the competition is getting tight- Oscar vs. Beaker is a strong matchup, as is Grover vs. Crazy Harry.
Jim Henson Division
- Kermit the Frog
- Grover
- Elmo
- The Swedish Chef
Frank Oz Division
- Cookie Monster
- Ernie
- Oscar the Grouch
- Gonzo
Dave Goelz Division
- Big Bird
- Count von Count
- Fozzie Bear
- Statler and Waldorf
Richard Hunt Division - Miss Piggy
- Bert
- Sam the Eagle
- Rowlf
Jim Henson Division
- Kermit the Frog - the green guy forever!
- Grover - he’s my old pal; how can I not vote for him?
- Dr. Teeth
- The Swedish Chef - bork, bork, bork!
Frank Oz Division
- Cookie Monster - ah nom, nom, nom!
- Ernie
- Oscar the Grouch
- Gonzo
Dave Goelz Division
- Big Bird
- Guy Smiley
- Fozzie Bear - wakka, wakka, wakka!
- Statler and Waldorf
Richard Hunt Division
- Miss Piggy
- Bert
- Mahna Mahna - doot, doo, dododo!
- Rowlf
Jim Henson Division
- Rizzo_the_Rat
- Grover
- Dr. Teeth
- The Swedish Chef
Frank Oz Division
- Cookie Monster
- Ernie
- Beaker
- Gonzo
Dave Goelz Division
- Big Bird
- Count von Count
- Fozzie Bear
- Statler and Waldorf
Richard Hunt Division
- Zoot
- Bert
- Mahna_Mahna
- Rowlf
I don’t know why they called him Crazy Herry. He seemed perfectly reasonable to me. Now Grover…there was an irrational fellow.
Jim Henson Division
-
Kermit the Frog
-
Grover
-
Dr. Teeth
-
The Swedish Chef
Frank Oz Division
-
Cookie Monster
-
Oscar the Grouch
-
Animal
Dave Goelz Division
-
Statler and Waldorf
Richard Hunt Division
-
Miss Piggy
-
Sam the Eagle
-
Dr. Bunson Honeydew
Joe
Jim Henson Division
- Kermit the Frog
- Grover
- Elmo
- The Swedish Chef
Frank Oz Division
- Cookie Monster
- Ernie
- Beaker
- Gonzo
Dave Goelz Division
- Big Bird
- Count von Count
- Janice
- Statler and Waldorf
Richard Hunt Division
- Miss Piggy
- Bert
- Sam the Eagle
- Rowlf
Damn. Marvin Suggs and Lew Zealand both knocked out in the first round. There goes my bracket.
I’ll have my picks for this round later.