Is it: Big Bad Voodoo Daddy’s You And Me And The Bottle Makes Three Tonight
?
My guess is “Three is A Magic Number” by Schoolhouse Rock, De La Soul and later Blind Melon.
8675309 is a phone number from Tommy Tutone. If that’s not the title of the song.
This one is going to be too easy, but breaking up the numbers kinda ruins it.
25* 6:4
25 or 6 to 4, Chicago
I thought it was 25 by six to four, but on review you’re right, consider the * something else (= maybe?)
My bro told me that when Chicago wrote the song, someone asked, “What time is it?” and that was the answer.
I guess the problem could have been phrased “3:35 or 3:34.”