Well, maybe you might disagree. Anyway, this idea came up when I was playing a fan-made sequel to Zak McCracken last night. Within the first ten minutes of playing the game, I had recognized the stargate’s theme from Stargate (I’m not really quite sure what to call it, but I think that it’s a fair description.) It also had the Imperial March, the love theme from the Monkey Island series, and so on.
You might argue that these aren’t musical jokes but musical references. While that’s true, I busted out laughing when I heard them because whoever made the decisions to put those particular bits in hit it just right.
Similarly, PDQ Bach. While a little PDQ Bach goes a long way, Schickele’s composing as PDQ is great in that the stuff is musically right but weird. It’s also often peppered with little references to other works.
This was brought up by Diogenes’ thread over in the Pit about the use of God Bless America during the seventh-inning stretch and Mtgman’s post in that thread, where I thought this would be a bad hijack but a decent thread.
So, what do you think? Are musical jokes incredibly funny, or are they the non-verbal equivalent of puns?