Mystery movies

Cafe Society
1

So I saw the movie Clue for like the 10th time recently. Love that movie, Tim Curry was perfect and the rest of the cast was great too. I liked the whole mystery aspect of the thing but one thing has always bugged me about it. It bills itself as a mystery, and of course the game is a mystery puzzle where you try to solve a murder, but in fact the characters know a lot more than the audience. There’s simply no way to “solve” the mystery until you get to the end of the movie because the clues are obvious only to the characters themselves

That got me wondering, are there any movies where all of the clues necessary to solve the mystery is laid out for the audience to actually solve? It would have to be something where the characters are not privy to any extra knowledge that is necessary to solve the mystery (but the knowledge may be used to help, of course, and to make a better movie)

Spoilers for the Usual Suspects below:

What bugged me about the film was that even though it was brilliantly constructed, there is no way for the viewer to figure out the mystery of Keyser Soze beforehand. We are only treated to Verbal’s version of events and without seeing the names on the wall of the police station he used as part of his story, there’s no way to determine if he was telling the truth or not

I guess I’m kind of looking for things like the old Encyclopedia Brown book series that I used to read as a kid. In those short stories, the main character deduces clues from the plot like dialogue, evidence, etc. and figures out the mystery by the end of it. However, all of the clues are written for the reader to catch as well. They were quite impressive to a young Yog Sosoth of only one or two vigintillions of years old. I guess I’m looking for a movie version of that type of mystery

2

One of my favorites is The Last of Sheila, as I’ve said on this Board many times before. They definitely do give you the clues.

The PBS Hercule Poirot films I’ve seen seem to do this, but I haven’t seen all of them.

3

The first episode of Foyle’s War qualifies (I think). It’s not a movie, but it is movie length. It’s also, very very good.
A few episodes in, the series falls back to the typical “audience could not possibly solve it” mode. Still good though.

4

A great made for TV movie that does this is “Rehearsal for Murder” by Richard Levinson and William Link. Not only is the killer a surprise, but the clues are all there – though not obvious until they are pointed out at the end (great cast, too). It’s on Youtube.

The Ellery Queen TV series (also by Levinson and Link) with Jim Hutton is definitely what you have in mind: they retained Queen’s “Challenge to the Reader,” where the story would stop and Queen would announce, “You now have all the clues you need to solve the mystery.”

Any adaptation of Agatha Christie novels, especially those done in the 70s and 80s and beyond. Sherlock Holmes would also fit.

I think the early Thin Man movies were that way (you tend to remember the dialog more than the plot). I know a modern viewer would never guess the identity of the killer in After the Thin Man, even given the clues.

5

Does “The Sixth Sense” count? That’s not really a whodunnit.