First of all, mods and admins, I’m sorry if this thread is in the wrong forum, but I wasn’t quiet sure where to put it.
Since I’ve never heard this brought up, I’m assuming that it must be a really bad idea, but I’ll ask about it anyway, because I’m a glutton for punishment.
Why do taxes need to be yearly? Why can’t they be based on every time you get paid? Keeping with our current progressive tax system, it could look something like (and I’m pulling numbers out of thin air here) if you get a $1,000 paycheck, you owe 12%. If you make $3,000 you pay 15% (or whatever the tax rates would be)
Granted, not everyone gets paychecks, some CEOs, like the ones who famously state that they only get paid $1.00/year, or something ridiculous like that get their money from owning stocks. OK, no biggie, every time the sell some stock to make some money, tax them on that. Actually, any time anybody sell stock, tax them on it.
The reason I’ve thought about it is, in debates on how to simplify that tax code, I’ve only heard that we should either go to a flat tax, or a national sales tax, but with this way, things would be simplified because you wouldn’t need to file W2s at the end of the year. Never worry about owing money, although you’d never get a refund either, because you’d know that you paid exactly the right amount of taxes, because it would be based on each paycheck that you earned and/or each stock that you sold, or, if you make money some other way, that would get taxed right then and there, so you wouldn’t have to worry about it at the end of the year.
So anyway, I’m guessing this probably wouldn’t work. Why not?