Yeah. This might be the dumbest rule yet.
What actually happened is not important. It was the intention. Really? Making a subjective call like that is idiotic. Do linemen intentionally go offside?
Yeah. This might be the dumbest rule yet.
What actually happened is not important. It was the intention. Really? Making a subjective call like that is idiotic. Do linemen intentionally go offside?
Since 2006, the season opener has had the Super Bowl Winner as the home team, that may be what you’re thinking of. But with a 16 game season, that gave only a 1 in 8 chance that it would work out - the 2 divisions would have to be facing each other, and the winner would have to be the home team. With the 17 game season, it’s closer to a 1/4 chance - either the 2 divisions are playing each other, or the 17th game is between the 2 divisions that the SB teams are in, and most likely they’d play in that case also (that’s why the Pats & Seahawks have a rematch this year). If AI isn’t lying to me, since 2006 these are all the rematches:
2014 Denver at Seattle(W), week 3.
2016 Carolina at Denver(W), week 1.
2022 Rams(W) at Cincinnati, week 3.
2023 Philadelphia at KC(W), week 11.
2025 Philadelphia(W) at KC, week 2.
2026 NE at Seattle(W), week 1.
So 6 rematches, 4 at the winner, 2 of which were Season openers.
We had virtually zero pass rush in the first half. Once we were far enough ahead in the 4th quarter and knew they had to pass, we were markedly better. We need to be ahead by the 4th quarter of games, otherwise it doesn’t bode well for us. I can’t see how we could go 17-0 especially with the brutal schedule we have. I’m thinking 12-5 or 11-6.
It’s the mention of intention that makes things seem silly. But my understanding was always that if the quarterback is in his (forward) throwing motion and gets hit, it’s an incomplete pass regardless of where the ball goes. I have a vague memory of Jimmy Johnson going nuts on the sideline over a similar call years ago, and I’m picturing Jeff Triplette as the ref. But I can’t find anything with a quick search so maybe I’m just wrong - it would have been about 30 years ago after all ![]()
It’s the mention of intention that makes things seem silly.
The intentional grounding rule is similarly silly… I mean, it even has “intentional” in the name!
The officials have to determine that a QB is “under pressure”. That is an extremely subjective and ambiguous determination, which requires a degree of prognostication and mind-reading if you want to do it accurately. You have to know he would have been likely to be sacked if he didn’t throw it, and that he felt pressured to get rid of the ball.
It’s Section 8.2 of the rules:
It is a foul for intentional grounding if a passer, facing an imminent loss of yardage because of pressure from the defense, throws a forward pass that is not in the direction and vicinity of an originally eligible offensive receiver.
In the same rule, section 4 of it is in regards to a “Delayed Spike”, and it requires additional mind-reading.
A passer, after delaying his passing action for strategic purposes, is prohibited from throwing the ball to the ground in front of him, even though he is under no pressure from defensive rusher(s).
So the delay must be for “strategic purposes”. I mean, you can guess based on circumstances, but it’s silly to base a rule on something you can’t possible know for sure.
That’s why almost every single game has at least one instance where commentators ask why a flag wasn’t thrown for intentional grounding, or questions why a flag was thrown. Part of the rule is objective, but there are subjective factors that are based solely on what an observing official assumes about the QB’s motives.
I’m not saying it’s impossible to make a reasonable assumption, but it is silly to codify something so ambiguous.
But my understanding was always that if the quarterback is in his (forward) throwing motion and gets hit, it’s an incomplete pass regardless of where the ball goes.
My understanding through years of watching the NFL is that it’s a forward pass if it looks like the ball is being propelled by the throwing motion. For example, if a ball is being moved forward but isn’t yet released, and a defender knocks it sideways out of the grip of the QB before the QB finishes throwing it, that’s a fumble rather than an incomplete pass. It’s usually clear that the ball wasn’t “thrown” if it moves in a direction other than the direction the ball is being thrown in and the ball itself hasn’t deflected off something after leaving the QB’s hand.
But whether the forward motion has taken place is a big part of it. And if the QB is moving the ball forward and his arm gets hit and the ball is knocked loose early and continues in the same trajectory it was moving before the QB is hit, that’s considered a throw even if the QB hadn’t meant to release it and it was just jarred loose.
I’ve watched a lot of slow-motion analyses of these plays and heard the considerations repeatedly, and this seems pretty consistent.
For example, if a ball is being moved forward but isn’t yet released, and a defender knocks it sideways out of the grip of the QB before the QB finishes throwing it, that’s a fumble rather than an incomplete pass.
This doesn’t match my understanding or how it has been called in games. I’m pretty sure the criteria was always if the QB’s arm had started the forward throwing motion, it’s incomplete even if it goes backwards.
Here’s a rules video from last year, cued up to 0:37: https://youtu.be/mpt7Zk0E0bw?t=37
On a totally unrelated subject, and also one from the Department of Worthless Statistics:
Lee Sharpe @LeeSharpeNFL
Here’s a rules video from last year, cued up to 0:37: https://youtu.be/mpt7Zk0E0bw?t=37
Hmm, I recall discussions about whether or not the ball was propelled by the QB.
And per this article, I’m probably remembering differently because the rules were changed recently; in 2021, then again in 2022.

A stealth change to the NFL’s passing rules made the Goff call correct.
It is so hard to keep track sometimes.
Its almost sad that Many Browns fans are hoping Baker slays at the next game against us.
It is so hard to keep track sometimes.
Now explain what’s a catch. ![]()
I agree, I was at the game, and I was annoyed it was 12 noon Texas time instead of 3 PM. Would have let me stay in church longer hanging out with friends.
Now explain what’s a catch.
I’m waiting for the league to formally institute the “we’ll call it a catch or a drop as we see fit” definition they definition don’t, no sirree, already use as a de facto standard
And just a moment ago the ball slips out of Bo Nix’s hand as it’s moving forward and they say it’s a fumble. (Though it’s blown dead because a Chief touched it after going out of bounds.)
So the officials don’t know the new rule either apparently.
So the officials don’t know the new rule either apparently.
Yeah, I think all of us NFL fans are owed a detailed explanation of how this is supposed to work. And why.
Yeah, I think all of us NFL fans are owed a detailed explanation of how this is supposed to work.
I think the best way to put it is “football is hard”.
By the way, K9 is looking like a freaking monster for the Chiefs. That was a great investment on their part.
…and now they got it right with another situation where the ball is knocked backward while going forward.
Holy crap the Broncos are getting a beatdown.
Holy crap the Broncos are getting a beatdown.
Not only did KC pick up Walker, but Emmet Johnson, rookie from Nebraska, is looking pretty damn good as well.
I only watched the YouTube highlights, but yikes, does the Broncos Defense know that its legal to tackle the ball carrier? It felt like every big play for the Chiefs started with a Bronco defender looking like me trying to make a tackle in the NFL.
Both teams were pretty sloppy, which isn’t that unusual for any team in the first week. It takes a bit to knock the rust off, plus you have rookies playing literally their first ever NFL game. But the Broncos were much worse.
I’m not sure the NFL would be a better game if we could have an exact on ambiguous technical definition of every rule because there are some things that really are a judgment call and are hard to legislate precisely. We would end up getting some counterintuitive rulings that followed the exact wording but that seemed wrong. I think it’s pretty remarkable actually how often the officials get it right because we think of the times they get it wrong and often we are very angry about that and it makes us not realize that these are the exceptions and that they get it right the first time at game speed the vast majority of the time. It’s actually kind of remarkable that they’re as good as they are when you realize that they’re not watching the God’s eye TV view and they’re running around on the field trying to track several different things at the same time. Which isn’t to say that there aren’t rules that could be updated but I don’t think it’s quite the unambiguous win that it might sound like at first.