Ninth Circuit Upholds Injunction Against AZ Immigration Law

[Bricker]

Well, I was wrong. But not a huge surprise, since I always regarded the preemption argument as the strongest one:

@Bricker

Well, if it gets overturned on the basis over preemption, I’ll be mildly surprised, but not shocked to my very core. I regard the preemption argument as wrong but tenable.

If it’s overturned because of some Equal Protection-type claim, I will humbly and sincerely eat helping after helping of crow.

So – I’m mildly surprised, but not shocked to my very core. I regarded the preemption argument as wrong but tenable, and it turns out to be tenable enough to be right.

Good call, Richard Parker.