Major spoilers ahead.
I’ve watched Obsession three times now, and I’ve been following some of the online discussion surrounding the film. One thing that troubles me is the tendency to interpret Bear as an allegory for male entitlement, or as an example of the supposedly hidden dangers lurking beneath the surface of apparently nice, lonely, socially awkward men.
I’m not going to argue that Bear behaves impeccably. He doesn’t. He makes some seriously questionable decisions, particularly as Nikki’s condition deteriorates. We can acknowledge that he behaves selfishly and causes enormous harm without making excuses for those actions. I think the severity of his badness is exaggerated and using “monster” or “predator” is too harsh a label. I think he’s more motivated by fear and confusion at being put in a completely unexpected situation than by entitlement. But I’m not going to pretend like he’s a great guy or anything.
But how much can we reasonably generalize from his behavior?
Bear begins as a lonely young man grieving his grandmother and his pet, struggling with romantic insecurity, and terrified of expressing his feelings to a woman he likes. He makes a wish using what appears to be an ordinary novelty item, without any realistic expectation that it will work.
Then the impossible happens. His wish apparently comes true, and he’s confronted with an increasingly frightening situation involving supernatural forces he doesn’t understand.
Bear is effectively being judged for how he responds to an extraordinary magical catastrophe. How much does that really tell us about the character of lonely men in the real world?
Imagine removing the magic from the story. What we’re left with is a lonely young man who enters a relationship with a woman who begins exhibiting increasingly disturbing behavior. He becomes concerned enough to take her to a hospital, where she refuses treatment.
That doesn’t automatically make him a good boyfriend, but neither does it establish that he’s a predator.
Eventually, Bear ends up taking his own life to break the spell on Nikki. I know he chickens out after taking the pills and unsuccessfully tries to vomit it up, but I think he deserves some credit for the initial decision to do that. An irredeemable monster would have just killed Nikki instead, or had her arrested or put her in a mental institution.
I can understand interpreting Nikki’s ordeal as an allegory for the violation of autonomy. What I question is whether Bear’s response to an impossible supernatural situation provides a meaningful basis for generalizing about the psychology of lonely men.
Even if we interpret Bear in the harshest possible light, he’s one fictional character. His behavior doesn’t tell us whether real men who are lonely, shy, romantically inexperienced, or afraid of rejection are harboring dangerous attitudes toward women.
There’s a legitimate distinction between criticizing entitlement and treating loneliness itself as a warning sign.
Is Obsession really an effective allegory for male entitlement, or are some viewers drawing broader conclusions from Bear’s character than the story can reasonably support?