Of the Big Four American chocolate candy companies, which is your favorite?

I’ll go for them too. They’re owned by the Swiss Lindt & Sprüngli, though, who also make good stuff. They taste a little different and sometimes it’s an acquired taste - I think they use a different process. I would also select them for repping home - I used to live by their factory. Chocolate production sadly does not smell good, however. They also haven’t been based out of Ghirardelli Square or even SF for decades.

ETA: Off the list, probably Mars, because they make Twix, right? Although I’ll dock them a few points for Three Musketeers, which is like a crappier version of Milky Way.

I like See’s candy.

oooh, I forgot about the Toblerone. I had my first one last year and damn, that’s good.
I think I may have sub-consciously blocked it out so I wouldn’t gain 70 pounds.

Hershey makes Reese’s Cups. End of decision-making process.

Central Pennsylvania girl here, grew up 12 miles away from Hershey, old enough to have been on an actual factory tour as a youngling.

Other companies’ milk chocolate just ain’t right. I like it OK if it’s adulterated, e.g. M&Ms, Snickers bars, Nestle Crunch bars.

Now, Hershey’s excuse for dark chocolate is an abomination and is best used for, I dunno, building brick walls (the brick part, not the mortar). Though they bought Scharffen Berger (which you can now purchase at Chocolate World) and haven’t ruined that yet.

I’m pro Scharffen Berger.

I also draw a distinction between Chocolate and Chocolate Candy.
For Chocolate Candy, I like Burdick’s Chocolate up here in the Northeast. It’s not big, but that’s probably why they are so good.
I also like Garrison Chocolates in Providence RI. Hubby bought me a chocolate bar from there with fruit and nuts in it that was sooo good. I want more. Again, not big at all.