Old mystery novel recommendations

I’m desperately looking for something to read. Recently I stumbled across Ngaio Marsh at the library, and quite liked her Roderick Alleyn detective novels. It took me only about a month to get through the eight or ten books the library had.

She struck me as similar to P. D. James, but not as dense–more breezy. Also, more lifelike than Christie.

Does anyone have any suggestions for similar writers from the 30s, 40s, 50s? Or more recently? I like Block, Westlake (and Stark), McBain, Ross Macdonald. Lansdale. Don’t like Burke, Evanovich, Ellroy. Like Christie, I can take or leave Grafton, John McDonald, Stout.

Have you tried Queen?

Ellery Queen perhaps ?

No. I’ve read anthologies from the magazine, but haven’t read any of the novels by/about Queen.

I’m gonna throw out two of my faves, but I’ll confess (“I did it! I put the overalls in Mrs. Murphy’s chowder!”) they might not be for everyone, and they’re a little hard to find…

Invisible Green and Black Aura, by John T. Sladek. The “Thackery Phin” novels. (They both get 4-star average reviews on Amazon.) They’re light, a bit whimsical, with characters that are caricatures, but with some elegant wordplay, some inventive mystery stuff, and just enough of a cockeyed view of life to make it interesting.

Also, try, “The Man Who Knew Too Much” by G.K. Chesterton. (Well, yes, and the Father Brown stories too!) These are somewhat Sherlockian in nature, and build up to an interesting climax. You might even call it a novel, rather than just a series of linked stories. (And, yes, with Chesterton, there is always a nasty note of 'tween wars antisemitism. We grimace and muster the grace to forgive him.)

(Best of all, Chesterton can be found for free. Project Gutenberg is your friend!)

Dorothy Sayers?

I didn’t see Dorothy Sayers (Lord Peter Wimsey) on your list. Your tastes seem to be similar to mine, and she’s my absolute favorite.

Also Dorothy Simpson’s Luke Thanet stories are in the same stye, if more modern.

I’d also like to throw in a recommendation for Lindsey Davis’ Marcus Didius Falco mysteries. They take place in Ancient Rome, but fit in with the ones you like.

If you like Ngaio Marsh, you’ll probably like Margery Allingham. Her detective Albert Campion starts out as a sort of frothy mix of Lord Peter Wimsey and Raffles, but in the middle to later books settles down into a more restrained though still fun character, with really fascinating settings/minor characters.

His manservant Lugg is one of my favorite sidekicks in all detective fiction, and his Scotland Yard pals are enjoyable too.

Speaking of Lord Peter Wimsey, have you tried the classic Dorothy L. Sayers mysteries starring him? Some of the later novels are a bit ponderous, but Whose Body? and Unnatural Death are more classic-mystery fun, for example.

ETA: double-ninja’d on Sayers!

I’ll start with the standards. Contemporaries of Marsh:

Margery Allingham has the Campion novels. I find them extremely variable in quality. Some are absolutely wonderful, such as Dancers in Mourning, Flowers for the Judge, or Tiger in the Smoke. Some, like The China Governess, leave me cold.

Josephine Tey’s Alan Grant novels.

Nicholas Blake’s (Cecil Day-Lewis (Daniel’s dad)) Nigel Strangeways books.

Dorothy L. Sayers has the Peter Wimsey books which are fantastic. They are not really like Marsh, though. Both funnier and denser/more literary in topic and approach.

(If you end up trying and liking Sayers, try the Ben Reese mysteries by Sally Wright. They are written now but are “historical.”)

Another contemporary of Marsh, though more like Christie’s Miss Marple: Patricia Wentworth’s Miss Silver novels.

Sounds like I should try Sayers. Peter Wimsey has been mentioned (positively) in a book by one of my favorite science fiction writers, now that I think of it.

Josephine Tey should not be missed and you can find her books in the public domain on the Project Gutenberg Canada site if you read digitally.

I have a hard time reading long works on the computer. Put a book in my hand, and I can sit for hours (with an occasional drink refill, or even a meal once in a while), but for whatever reason–the width of the screen, the brightness, the inability to lay in bed with one side of my laptop tucked into my elbow–I can’t just sit and read extensively on a screen. I can read stuff like the SDMB or news websites for hours, but not digital books. Maybe 50+ years of reading paper have made me set in my ways.

I can’t read on a computer screen very well. My Kindle is the most beautiful thing ever, though. I think it’s all about screen width, spacing, and backlighting.

Here’s good news: Ngaio Marsh wrote something like 50 books in the Alleyn series. They’re pretty cheap and you might be able to buy lots on ebay.

Marsh is my favorite, and Dorothy Sayers after that.

For something more contemporary, I like Ruth Rendell. Her settings are recent, but her style of detective is in the model of Alleyn and Wimsey. His name is Wexford. Great character.

Another vote for Rendell. She also has a few under the name Barbara Vine.

Raymond Chandler and Dashiel Hammet are not to missed. Robert Parker’s Spenser is a modern day Chandler and well worth a look.

I’ve read all (or almost all–there’s a posthumous collection of Hammet’s unpublished work in the Reading library that I can’t get into–there’s usually a perfectly good reason that an author working for money didn’t publish something in their lifetime–i.e., it sucked and nobody wanted to pay money for it) of Chandler and Hammet, and, yes, liked them. I’ve flipped through pages of Parker’s Spenser in the library and he didn’t catch my interest.

I’m a HUGE fan of Fredric Brown. I knew of him as a science fiction and fantasy writer, but I was reading The Annotated Alice, and Martin Gardner had a note about Brown’s mystery novel The Night of the Jabberwock, so I had to pick it up. It was in an omnibus edition of four mysteries. The guy who sold it to me said “Huh! I didn’t know he wrote mysteries!”
Boy, did he. I can highly recommend his work. Brown’s writing is a model of crisp, simple prose. He came up with some of the most wonderful, involved ideas. But his mysteries are bigger on character and mood. The volume I started with included:

The Fabulous Clipjoint – Brown’s first novel. It won him an Edgar. Definitely worth reading. It introduced his detective team of Ed and Am Hunter, who showed up in several later novels and stories. In this first one, Ed’s father is murdered in an apparent mugging in Chicago, and Ed enlists the help of his carny uncle Ambrose to help him track down the killer. A coming-of-age novel as well as a mystery.

The Screaming Mimi – atmospheric mystery where a down-and-out homeless reporter witnesses the attempted murder of a woman in a hotel lobby through the glass. Her dog leaps up and pulls off her dress, leaving her nude (she’s a stripper, it turns out, and this was their act). He vows to sober up and track down her attempted killer. Beautifully told, with unexpected twists. It was filmed (with Gypsy Rose Lee!), but I’ve never seen the film, which I suspect isn’t at all faithful. This book actually recalls Robert Bloch’s work.

The Night of the Jabberwock – a small-town newspaper editor is approached by a man who says he is to recruit the editor into a secret society called The Vorpal Blades, which knows the REAL secrets behind Lewis Carroll’s works. He leads the editor into a house, where there’s a bottle on a table that says “Drink me”. The recruiter takes the bottle and does – and falls down dead.

Knock 3-1-2 a murder told from multiple points of view, including the murderer’s I’m told this one has been filmed, too.

Carnival of Crime – a collection of short Brown mysteries, including one story where the victim is the reader.

A company called MacMillan published several volumes of Brown’s old pulp stories back in the 1980s and 90s. The hardcover editions have become collector’s items, but some of the paperback editions had big print runs, and can still be found – Homicide Sanitarium, Before She Kills, Pardon my Ghouliosh Laughter, Thirty Corpses Every Thursday, The Freak Show Murders were all printed in paperback editions.

For a time inj the 1980s and 1990s it seemed as if they were rteprinting a Brown mystery every year – **Murder Can Be Fun, The Far Cry, ** and others appeared in paperback then. I don’t see them in used book stores much anymore (whern I can find used book stores), but you ought to be able to find them online, or in libraries. The Salt Lake City library used to have a fine collection of Browns.

Not old school but just as good. You may enjoy Christopher Fowler’s Bryant and May series.

He’s a terrific writer and the books are often laugh out loud funny.

Have you ever tried an e-ink e-reader (like the Kindle (not to be confused with the Kindle Fire))? It’s designed to be as much like reading ink on paper as possible—not like reading a computer screen. And especially among “old mysteries,” there are books that may be hard to track down in print but that have readily available electronic versions.
You might want to browse the Classic Myseries blog, which has reviews/recommendations of classic mystery books (reviews are available in podcast form, but I just read the written descriptions).
And I’ll second Brown, Sayers, and Chesterton.