You know, maybe it’s just me, but I always find it really disturbing how people will just take away the possessions of a little kid without warning. I mean, what does that teach the kid, it’s OK to take other peoples’ stuff without asking them? Would you do that to an adult? (Well, I guess some people do - I once had a “friend” who came over to “help” when I wasn’t there and tried to convince my spouse to just toss a lot of my clothes and books to make more room, as if I wouldn’t somehow notice the difference. It didn’t help that this nosy neighbor had entirely different ways of determining “value” than I did - wanting to toss my $1,200 band uniform, which I wore to gigs that earned money, because it was “frumpy” and “no one wears plaid anymore”. Um, it’s what you wear when playing bagpipes, and I earn money for wearing it, that’s why I should keep it?.. but I digress.)
Likewise, I find it disturbing when someone says “Oh, my husband/wife had a bunch of X and I tossed it because I was tired of it taking up space”. Um… it’s not your stuff? It’s one thing if the other person says “Could you clean this up, toss crap out, whatever it takes to clean up” but doing it behind their back?
Maybe I’m off base here, but it seems to me you’re not teaching your child how to make choices, or clean up, or get rid of excess, and isn’t childhood when you should start doing that? “Timmy, we don’t have room for all these toys. You have to choose which ones to keep and which ones we’ll give away to someone who doesn’t have toys”.
Then again, I was the sort of child with a disturbingly accurate memory who, if something went missing, would cry inconsolably for days and days over it. Which might mean my hoarder-tendencies started very early. I might have done better if my parents had taught me young to make “keep or toss” choices, said if I wanted to buy a new book I had to make room on the shelf by giving up an old one, and so forth. Maybe I grew up expecting pixies to magically make the clutter disappear. Having stuff “go away” when I wasn’t looking just made me want to hold onto the remaining stuff all the harder, even if I learned crying over it wasn’t acceptable and stopped doing it, even if I learned speaking of it was unacceptable and I stopped doing it.
My apologies if this comes off as overly critical, and clearly how you treat a 6 month old would be different than how you treat a 6 year old when it comes to too many toys, but maybe some of us would have done better with the clutter if we had been forced to make choices rather than having someone else do it for us? Is two too young to start doing that? I don’t know.