My two oldest are now 12 and 10, so I’ve had a few attempts at passing on some of my childhood favorites. Some stuck with them and others haven’t. I’ve decided to expose them to but not force feed anything (which of course wouldn’t work).
The Hobbit was probably their favorite. For some reason though, Eldest didn’t cotton to LOTR. She read through to the first 100 pages or so of The Return of the King before just stopping on the grounds that “nothing was happening”.
Other books that Eldest enjoyed, but not apparently on a similarly worldview-affective level as it did me, included Charlotte’s Web, The Little Prince, and The Phantom Tollbooth. (La Segunda has only so far read Charlotte’s Web.) I’ve attempted to get them hooked on The Jungle Book (the original Kipling, not the Disney cartoon) and about a dozen or so hand-picked adventures of Sherlock Holmes, which also hasn’t really caught their fancy.
My Eldest’s one-line response on Charlotte’s Web: “it was fun”. When asked how she felt about the manner of Charlotte’s passing: “Well, spiders don’t live that long.” (I guess they knew too much biology before reading the book, I just know that scene blindsided both me and my wife as children to tears)
The Little Prince? “I liked it OK, but when a boy at school saw me reading it he said he read it when he was 9 and it was like the gayest book ever.”
They both did get very caught up in The Chronicles of Narnia and various books ly Classical Mythology though, as I did as a child, and have tore through the Harry Potter and “Series of Unfortunate Events” books, as well as several other YA sci-fi series I have not read, like series beginning with The Time Travelers by Linda Buckley-Archer (The Gideon Trilogy), and some rather dark and dystopian ones, such as the Shadow Children series by Margaret Haddix or The Hunger Games by Suzanne Collins.
I’m hoping to get Eldest to read Watership Down by Richard Adams this summer, along with the Prydian Chronicles by Lloyd Alexander, the Tripod Trilogy of books by John Christopher and eventually, the Amber books by Roger Zelazny.