I actually have an original artwork by a recognized artist, so I actually got to pick that one! (But it’s in my bedroom. But it would also be my wall hanging of choice, since collectable ducks aren’t my kind of kitsch.)
But the Gun Rack (again, better than the rest of the choices,) and pit bull (I’d rather have a cat, but if I had to get a dog might as well get a strong one,) dragged me down to an unrecognizable mishmash.
I think that’s what you’re supposed to do, isn’t it? Not put in what you actually have, but what you would have if you could. At least, that’s how I took it.
I got middle middle, which is pretty accurate, I guess, based on what’s in my family’s house. (I still live with my parents.) But many choices were hard because we actually have a lot of stuff from different categories. I guess if I had been allowed to choose everything we have, we would have turned out a cross between middle and old money–which I guess is accurate since my grandparents were wealthier than we are, and some of my great-grandparents were very rich–but of course, in their day, many of those wealthy ancestors would have been considered nouveau riche. What we don’t have is much working-class stuff or fancy new electronics.
Of course, the problem with that is figuring out what you would have if you could. Partly this is because I have limited style sense, and partly this is because some of their options were so goofy.
Apparently liking electric toys is nouveau riche (Hey, I read to…I just keep the books in the bedroom) but I also had things from a few other classes.
I wish they’d had a cat in with the dog choices. I’m not a dog person, and there were too many large breeds–nothing really fit, and only the toy poodle came close.
Old Money, but my room looked like shit, so lunch will be at the country club with Beadalin, Ginger, cher3, Sarahfeena and any other People Like Us™ I missed.
Not a very good version of this game because the choices are too limited. For example, I don’t have best sellers in my living room, but I do have antique books. Those aren’t the same thing, nor are they antique decoys. Similarly, I have no dog, and will never have a dog unless I go blind, but if I did have a dog, it would be a rescue greyhound like my family had when I was growing up. There’s a more extensive quiz in the back of Class: A Guide through the American Status System that we’ve found more accurate when used as a party game. However, none that I’ve seen does a very good job once you throw “student” or social activism into the mix, or accounts well for cultural variations even in the U.S.
All writers of these books (e.g., Bobos in Paradise) see themselves as able to step outside the taxonomy, so they’re always covertly praising their own choices in wine, music, or decor.
For those of you who have a sign-in for the New York Times (and if you don’t- sniff, how common ), you may find it interesting to compare your class from Chintz or Shag to your class from this calculator.
I come out as top fifth in those. You wouldn’t know to look at me (or, evidently, my taste in furniture).