Here’s the review from today’s Sydney Morning Herald of our performance last Saturday night:
Warming fare, and not just for Winter
Die Jahreszeiten (The Seasons), Haydn
Sydney Philharmonia Choir
Mats Nilsson
Opera House, 10 July
Peter McCallum
It is a sad fact that when he came to write his last oratorio, The Seasons (1801), some of Haydn’s most inspired and expressive thoughts went into the orchestral introduction of the Winter music, depicting the onset of fog, cold, and, in Haydn’s case, old age and death.
“The Seasons has finished me off,” he later declared; he was to spend most of the remaining eight years of his life plagued by illness and too weak to write down the musical ideas which still scurried around his brain. But, characteristically, he had cheered himself up by the end of the piece with a folksy spinning chorus and thoughts of the afterlife. Whenever he thought of God, he said, it made him cheerful.
For the rest, Haydn was content to paint a series of charming, if more conventional, tableaux.
Working with a trite text, parts of which he evidently found irritating (which had been assembled by his friend and supporter, Baron van Swieten) Haydn, for his last major work constructed some of his most naively pictorial music. The shape of each part is a short instrumental introduction followed by short solo and choral numbers leading to a central set piece, followed by solo dialogues to a final chorus. Thus Spring leads to a gentle pastoral, Summer to an electric storm, Autumn to a hunt and a drinking chorus, and Winter to a cosy spinning chorus enlivened by a moral tale of virtue rewarded and lasciviousness punished.
The Philharmonia’s chorus work, under Mats Nilsson, was precise with well-rounded balance. The fugues, such as at the close of Spring and Autumn (a “drunken fugue” as Haydn called it) were admirably even without harsh accent, though in one or two moments one could have tolerated lustier vigour.
The orchestra had moments of excellence from winds and fine open-air horn playing during the hunt scene, although the end was scrappy. Nilsson stresses fullness of sound, preferring to maintain ongoing continuity and flow over the inner cadences of phrases, sometimes diminishing their sense of question-answer dialogue. Haydn and van Swieten peopled the abstract world of nature’s realm with suitably simple peasants.
Sara Macliver as Hanne the farmer’s daughter sang, as always, with liquid purity, never more so than in the clear sustained notes full of expectant stillness over soft plucked strings just before the summer storm.
Overcoming earlier moments of anxiety over pitch, tenor David Hamilton opened wonderfully in the closing decorative passages of his agitated restless Winter aria, while Andrew Schroeder had serious solidity as Simon the farmer. Rich and warming winter fare.