I have access to a computer that has Photoshop Elements on it. I’m trying to remove the background from a few scanned album pages using the Magic Extractor but it’s removing more than the background.
The main reason I am trying to remove the background is I had to stick some images together and while the content matches the background does not. My ultimate goal once I have the pictures removed is to put them on a sample of the book background.
These tools do an imperfect job at best - they generally rely on differences between the background and foreground object, and when the background colors are patterned and close to the foreground, they’ll make mistakes. So often, some hand-editing is required.
What I would recommend you do is trim your photos down by a couple of pixels, rather than try to get it exact. I haven’t used elements, although I do use Photoshop from time to time. There are a couple of easy ways to take an oval picture like you have and trim it a bit. Or you could zoom in by hand and go around the picture removing pixels that look ‘wrong’ with the eraser tool.
Here’s a tutorial for making a ‘clipping mask’ in Elements: Clipping Mask. You want to make one that’s an oval just slightly smaller than the original photo.