[QUOTE=dublos]
This is indeed where I get confused. And i think that both quotes are hinging on the same fact that I don’t get. Why is it that 50 foot pounds of thrust move the same plane 2, 3, even 10 miles per hour? Is it the same reason that moving onto the treadmill from a “normal ground” speed of 5 miles per hour will not actually stop when the ground underneath it starts moving back at 5 miles per hour?
[/quote]
Careful here. There’s a difference between moving the plane at X miles per hour on a runway and keeping the plane stationary on a treadmill that moves X mile an hour.
[QUOTE=dublos]
I am still seeing this as “the ground is moving backward at x miles per hour, the thrust of the plane is moving it forward at x miles per hour, x from both sides cancel each other out.”
[/QUOTE]
Here’s the issue. You’re looking at it as if the basic impetus is a speed rather than a force.
Perhaps the fact I’m not explaining is this: F=ma. Force equals mass times acceleration. If the forces aren’t balanced, the object (plane, car, whatever) must accelerate.
Let’s back up to a more intuitive analogy. You’re sitting in your car, cruising down the highway at a steady speed. Your foot’s on the gas, the engine’s delivering torque to the wheels, and the wheels are applying force to the road. With me so far?
But you’re not accelerating; you’re staying at a steady speed. That’s because the wheel force is exactly balanced by opposing forces: hysteresis force in the tires and air resistance forces being the two big ones. All forces add to zero, and you don’t accelerate. If any of those forces change, your speed will change (because F=ma, or rather a =F/m).
For example, you let off on the gas. The force pushing the car forward is now less than the force opposing the car, and you slow down (because F=ma, and negative total F means a negative total a). The nice thing here is that the air resistance force is a function of your velocity, So, as you slow, the air resistance force decreases, and eventually the forces are again equal, and you’re travelling at a constant velocity.
Likewise, if a tailwind suddenly springs up, the air resistance decreases, the forces are no longer equal, and (unless you let off the gas) your car accelerates (because F=ma).
Now, back to the airplane. Look at it from a force point of view, not a speed point of view. During a normal take off (on a runway, not a treadmill), the engines produce a force. That force is resisted by wheel friction, tire hysteresis, and air resistance. Normally the engine thrust is greater than the resisting forces and the plane accelerates (F=ma, right?).
However, you could probably roughly match engine thrust force to some steady speed. If the engine produces just a little bit of force, the plane will accelerate to (say) 1 mph, at which time the air resistance force increases just enough to completely balance the thrust, and the plane stays at a constant 1 mph until it plows off the end of the runway.
With a little more thrust force, the plane will accelerate to 2 mph, at which time the air resistance force increases just enough to completely balance the thrust, and the plane stays at a constant 2 mph until it plows off the end of the runway. And on and on and on.
But once you put the plane on a treadmill, this force balance is no longer valid, because if the plane stays stationary, there is no air resistance.
Suppose you fire the engine up to produce a little bit of force–the same little bit of force that pushed the plane to go a constant 1 mph on the runway. What happens?
The thrust force is the same, but the opposing forces are different: there’s no air resistance. So the forces don’t balance when the treadmill goes 1 mph. It’s a different set of forces.
So what does happen to the plane on the treadmill? Well, it depends on what you assume happens to the other forces–the hysteresis and the bearing friction and so forth. Different assumptions lead to different answers…but one thing that’s for sure is that in this case, the overall forces are different from the non-treadmill case, so the acceleration (and the velocity) must be different too.