[QUOTE=dublos]
I still feel like I’m missing something here, but it may take someone with a treadmill, roller skates and a fan mounted on a backpack to prove it to me.
I cannot escape from two things that keep nagging at me. 1) I’m rather firmly planted on the ground, really good roller skates or not, and 2) the ground (well, the treadmill) is moving in the opposite direction I am trying to move, even if the air above the ground (treadmill) is not.
None the less, it is starting to make sense to me and overcome those two things nagging at me.
[/QUOTE]
I think you’re getting the hang of it. But you might have some difficulty designing an experiment to prove it unless you reduce the problem to simple elements.
There are many things in our existance that don’t make much sense at first and seem to violate our human observations, such as “why, if the earth is rotating, don’t we fly off?” and the fact that a feather and a bowling ball fall at the same rate on earth in a vacuum. Another might be the innate feeling that a person wearing roller skates is not totally isolated from the ground, and indeed, if that were always true, you couldn’t skate across the rink! The reason you can skate is partly due to the selective application of friction. You can turn your skates sideways and push off, for example.
Newton’s laws tell us that we should not be able to detect movement in a non-accelerating car, for example. But if you are seated in a moving car, that would be hard to believe, right? Was Newton wrong? No, your senses are detecting other clues, such as sight, vibration, sound and the dashboard speedometer. If you could travel at 100 MPH without those clues, you wouldn’t be able to tell that you are moving at all. You’d probably have to go into space to try this out, though.
Also, while your fanonbackpersononskates is an accurate analogy to the planeonarunway in theory, the difference between the two paired forces (fan vs. rollerskate friction, plane engines vs. tire friction) might influence a test. I suspect there might be only a little difference between the force applied by the fan and the resistance of the skates as compared to the diff between those big, powerful engines on a plane and the relatively little rolling resistance. Nevertheless, the principle is the same.
Looking at it another way, if you want to compute the rate of fall of a bowling ball in air, you could probably ignore air resistance, at least for a while. But air resistance would be a huge factor to a feather, and could not be ignored. See what I’m getting at?
When I took physics, we did experiments with dry ice, hocky puck-sized discs that enabled us to remove almost all the friction factors from the experiments. Perhaps having skates made of dry ice would be a good test! Can you envision what would happen to a puck sitting on a smooth-surfaced treadmill, with very litle friction between them when the treadmill started moving? Compare that to a standard hockey puck on a rough treadmill. No friction – no motion imparted. Much friction – much motion transferred. Some friction – some motion transferred.