Plaster on ceilings - why?

No such distinguishing need be made.

plaster , short for plaster of paris, is nothing but gypsum… and that explains where you got your additional words from…

Lathe is nothing but a way to create a wall or ceiling in situe starting with lathe and plaster powder . So what ?

The modern way is drywall, which is simply pre-fab’d sheeting, and no lathe is then needed.

Many homes have plaster (whether pre-fab or painted in situ ) walls, as well as plaster ceilings.

That is because it bonds together well, and it remains quite stiff, so that if it does pull off one part of the wall or ceiling stucture, it probably won’t be noticed.
Now you can use a timber or artificial timber for walls, and the OP is perhaps asking why ceilings are better done with plaster ?

Well the reason is that the builder can easily look along the wall and floor and make sure its very very flat. But the ceiling structure is often the lower end of the pre-fab gable,
and the builder has difficulty putthing is head up there ,and has difficulty doing anything about small alignment problems. The pre-fab gables also do quite some settling, because they never held weight and then they have roofing on them… and they are getting heated up in the summer.

And even if the ceiling is attached to a floor, he would of course prefer the floor side to be precise, which then leaves the lower, ceiling, side to be slightly incorrect.

I am just explaining some of the sins that the comment “hides a multitude of sins”…
refers to .

Other sins include light fittings being removed, the problems with water leaks causing drooping (plaster resists water damage… not immune but it has to be attacked by acids for quite a while… ), and also the lower weight of plaster… and if does fall, less damage is done.

The builders just like it, and it does the job.

back in the early 90’s … bought a house built in 1968 (this had been down south in dallas, texas) … those selling it were the originals owners … the husband had been a building contractor … could see it in different ‘upgrade’ aspects. anyway, three bedrooms and two bathrooms … the master bathroom, in the tub alcove, had lathing (metal mesh) and 2½-3" thick plaster … the second bathroom had only drywall.

one remarkable feature of plaster is the sound absorption qualities … drywall offers nothing close. then again … the plaster weighs a ton (literally) … so the foundation needs to be able to support the extra weight. also … plaster is more impervious to damp conditions when compared with normal drywall which just crumbles. of course, they have newer types of drywall nowadays … the green stuff which is humidity/moisture resistant and then actual cement-board which, purportedly, is water-proof.

Listens to the echo off my lathe and plaster walls. What sound absorption? They make my house sound like an echo chamber in an old recording studio.

Thank you Isilder for such an excellent run down of the question at hand … though I have a couple of differences of opinion, and I assume these are strictly local variations …

One big advantage of lathe-and-plaster over drywall is durability … I’m buying a 120-year-old house and the original lathe-and-plaster downstairs is in remarkably great shape, no way would drywall have lasted over a century and look this good … I did some poking around the web and came across the This Old House site and they are very strongly in favor of repairing lathe-and-plaster, and they included clear techniques for the repair of said wall coverings … drywall is certainly cheaper, but that doesn’t mean better …

Now, I agree that texturing/popcorning covers a few sins, but not near as many as this thread seems to imply … if we want our texturing/popcorning to look good, we really do have to finish the drywall smooth … or the garfs and screw divots will still be obvious and make the final product look crappy … secondly, if you have kids in your household, you will be washing your walls regularly … as robby’s wife correctly pointed out in the zombie section of this thread … washing a popcorn ceiling is near impossible, and most texturing is only slightly better … textured walls look great, a sign of wealth, and some rich person can just tell their maid staff to wash the damn walls … but if you don’t have a maid staff, maybe the smooth look is good enough …