[QUOTE=InvisibleWombat]
Making the bestseller list doesn’t make you a good writer, but it doesn’t make you a bad one, either.
[/QUOTE]
Of course making the bestseller list doesn’t make you a bad writer, but that’s not the point I’ve seen anyone post..
For one thing, unless you’re actually in the publishing/writing business you probably don’t understand that bestseller is as much a category/type/genre as science fiction or mysteries. There are ways that bestsellers are standardly written that are different from the ways other types of novels are. Search Amazon for titles like “writing the bestselling novel.” You’ll find the “secrets” of writing bestsellers. (Most of them are meaningless things like writing short chapters, from a variety of points of view, and driving the plot.)
Obviously these aren’t sufficient or anybody could do it, right? Wrong. Anybody can write a bestseller-type novel. Many people do. You’ve never heard of them because they don’t sell enough copies, but they are structurally and stylistically identical. (How do I know about them?: because after each new person becomes a bestseller, a horde of novels as exactly alike as possible as touted as the next so-and-so. Check the ads in any book publication for the imitation Dan Browns you’ll never hear of next year.) Many bestseller writers are like Dan Brown, somebody whom lightning struck. He’s been writing the same way for a while, but suddenly he caught fire.
The other strange dirty secret of bestsellerdom is that once lightning strikes, it takes an almost willful attempt to lose that aura. Bestselling authors keep on being bestsellers even after most of their devoted fans agree that their latest books are utter crap. But the diminishing returns take a very long time to diminish. Habit is a difficult thing to break.
Publishing is a business. Bestselling writers are businesspeople, giving the consumers what they want. I don’t fault them for this for a moment, but I’m in the business and I recognize it for what it is.
There are good writers who sell very well. Always have been, and hopefully always will be. But they are simply a different part of the business than bestsellers.
What this all reminds me of is the quote from a baseball player after a tough series of negotiations with the owners. It went something like, “Every time we said that baseball was a sport, they said it was a business, and every time we said it was a business they said it was a sport.”
Bestsellers are like sports. Totally unimportant in the greater scheme of things, but people’s lives revolve passionately around teams. Does that make sports terrible? No. Can we wish that people would put some of that passion into politics or the environment or charity? Certainly. (Some do both.) We should all be at least self-aware enough to recognize the place and value of all the aspects of our lives, and not make false claims about how everything is of equal value.
All books are equal but some are more equal than others.*
*A literary allusion. If you don’t get it, find out the book it came from and read it now. Its better than a bestseller. 