As Dracula, I still think Bela Lugosi is the best. That’s not nostalgia or tradition speaking – of all the Draculas, he was the only one that convinced me that he really was an ancient slavonic nobleman.
Christopher Lee turned in the most faithful performance, but in Jess Franco’s Count Dracula, not the 1957 Hammer film.
The choice for overall best production is given, by many discriminating critics, to the BBC version starring Louis Jourdan, who I think I’d give second place after Bela (much as I loved Langella).
Not in the running:
John Carradine (twice)
Jack Palance
Richard Roxburgh (from Van Helsing)
Marc Warren (who? He played a definitely offbeat Dracula in a Granada 2006 version, which had David Suchet – Hercule Poirot! – as van Helsing)
Sad to hear about Christopher Lee’s passing. I didn’t know about it until this thread.
I know that Matheson wrote (and introduced, for the first time, the idea of Dracula going after a woman because she was the reincarnation of his Lost Love, and idea that would be re-used in Coppola’s version. I think Matheson lifted it from Balderston’s script for The Mummy) it. It’s still not great. Much as I love Palance, this version just doesn’t do it for me.
I think a large part of it is that “Castle Dracula” looks like they shot it in Dan Curtis’ neighbor’s home. Palance has the coziest Dracula’s Castle of any version I’ve seen. I couldn’t imagine it having bats or wolves or spiders or armadillos in it.
I’d like to get the count (sic) up to 20 at least before posting a poll.
Here’s the list so far (I hope I got them all)…
Christopher Lee
Bela Lugosi
Gary Oldman
Max Schreck
Frank Langella
Jess Franco
Louis Jourdan
John Carradine
Jack Palance
Richard Roxburgh
Marc Warren
Leslie Nielsen
Dominic Purcell
Gerard Butler
Keep in mind that the voters will determine the worthiness of the portrayal(s) so self-censorship at this stage is not required.
Just something to whittle down the 500+ linked to above (Post #3) to a reasonable poll size.
Jess Franco was a director, not an actor (well, he does have 99 acting credits on IMDB, but it’s mostly voice overs or uncredited extra work). He directed Christopher Lee as the Count in 1970’s Count Dracula, aka El Conde Dracula, but he never played Dracula himself.
Which reminds me, what about Klaus Kinski in the remake of Nosferatu? Despite the Max Schreck inspired makeup, that character was definitely named Dracula.
Jonathan Rhys Meyers played Dracula in the NBC TV series of that title last season. It was bad, but he did a creditable job.