[QUOTE=lissener]
Well, that’s a bit different from “So, when you say ‘most US climates’, you accept the secession of the Confederacy? It doesn’t grow well in the South at all. Man, do I hate gardening books that assume we’re all living in Vermont.”
[ol]
[li]Yes, I do say most US climates.[/li][li]That still doesn’t equal your non-sequitur “everywhere but the CSA.”[/li][li]It would appear that it does, in fact, grow well in most of the South, your immediate surroundings not withstanding.[/li][li]And yeah, when I lived in Chicago I found that most mainstream gardening books were not written exclusively for Chicago’s climate. Living in Seattle I have discovered that most mainstream gardening books are not written exclusively for the Pacific Northwest. So, you’re suggesting that all gardening books should either[list=a][/li][li]encompass all possible climates and microclimates, or[/li][li]be written with your backyard as the exclusive reference point[/li][/ol]
[/list]
You know, I’m sorry if I come off as pissy here. But I realize that not all places in the US are exactly the same climate. I’ve lived in Texas, Illinois, and Washington; how could I not know that? I explicitly acknowledged this when I very consciously said “*most *US climates.” To come back with the accusation that my helpful suggestion was so tunnel-visioned and ignorant that I must be idiot enough to draw the US’s borders according Civil War maps, and that I solipsistically believe that everyone lives in Vermont–in short, because I accidentally left out the exact phrase “except for Zsofia’s backyard”–was pretty dang pissy of *you *in the first place. I’m not seeing where my attempt at being helpful, and my explicit acknowledgement that there were indeed places it would *not *thrive, deserved that kind of whiny sarcasm.
[/QUOTE]
I’m sorry if I came off as pissy - it’s just been very frustrating to, say, try to figure out when to plant bulbs and get “before the ground freezes” in all the books. If the ground ever froze here we’d be so scared we’d pee in our pants!
My only point was that while in a lot of the country rhubarb grows like a real weed, it doesn’t here. My mother’s tried to grow it, I’ve tried to grow it, nobody I know grows it and the books say “don’t bother in the South”. Sure, maybe you can grow it - if I wanted to I bet I could grow just about anything given enough equipment and knowledge, but all the advice of “oh, just stick it in the ground and watch out!” is simply not true everywhere.