I recently tried the same thing (basically; some differences in what I considered “albums”, but I’ll go with your use here). Here was mine:
Chronic Town - 1,000,000
Murmur - Sitting Still
Reckoning - Harborcoat
Fables of the Reconstruction - Maps And Legends
Life’s Rich Pageant - I Believe
Dead Letter Office - Bandwagon
Document - Exhuming McCarthy
Eponymous - Gardening At Night (Different Vocal Mix)
Green - You Are The Everything
Out of Time - Me In Honey
The Best of R.E.M. - Perfect Circle
Automatic for the People - Nightswimming
R.E.M. Singles Collected - Fall On Me
Monster - What’s the Frequency, Kenneth
New Adventures in Hi-Fi - Electrolite
R.E.M: In the Attic - Time After Time Etc. (Live Medley: Time After Time/Red Rain/So. Central Rain)
Up - At My Most Beautiful
Reveal - Beachball
In Time: Best of R.E.M. 1998-2003 - The Great Beyond
Around the Sun - Leaving New York