I LOVE that. It’s really disturbing but totally appropriate.
Another minor rant: I went to my local YMCA a couple of weeks ago and took my kids to swim. My son is 7 and has become a really good swimmer (at least in a standard pool) and loves to practice swimming from place to place under water, skimming along the bottom, going as far as he can, etc. My daughter is 3 and can’t swim, so I spend a lot of time shuttling her up and down the pool, teaching her to float and kick and all that jazz.
So my son’s doing his thing about 1/3 of the pool away while I’m keeping an eye on him and floating his sister. Something important to note - the water was just a little higher than his waist - he was easily able to stand up. One of the lifeguards came up to me to tell me that regardless of whether the child was a competent swimmer or not, my son could be only an arm’s length from me. Really???
Now, part of me gets it. I sure the heck don’t want something to happen to my son and although it’s the lifeguard’s job to make sure that the rules are followed, I still hold myself responsible for making sure they walk, not run, aren’t doing anything unsafe, etc. And even though I felt like I was being vigilant, the fact remains that I’m trying to be vigilant while at the same time managing another kid. But the requirement that he be no further than an arm’s length away, especially when he can stand up easily and is a fairly competent swimmer who passed all his summer swim tests at that same pool, really just killed the whole experience. Plus, how the heck is he supposed to practice his skills if he’s only an arm’s length away? My arms aren’t that long - probably not even more than 2 or so feet. That’s really damn close.
So I spent almost the entire time either trying to keep close or calling to him to come back, stay close, stop swimming away, no, I’m sorry you can’t play over there until I get there and those are the rules. It really sucked and I think we’ll try really hard to stick to a different pool when I’m taking him and his sister swimming.