Over the past few years, I have pulled three 2.5" drives from old laptops and put them into new enclosures designed to make them portable. No problem - just snap into the case and attach to USB on computer. I also liberated a 3.5" drive from its enclosure and put it into a media player with great results.
I decided to do a couple recently. I had three Sata 2.5" drives and ordered Sata enclosures for them. None of the three drives works correctly in either of the enclosures. They all start spinning and the light comes on, but sometimes the computer fails to recognize a hdd is attached, even though it says the driver is installed. Other times, the drive is recognized with a volume label of SERVICEV002 and a capacity of 3.24 gigs, but this is a 80 gig drive!
All drives and cases came from different sources. What could be wrong?