I always recommed Carmen to those wanting to take their first step in opera. First, the music will be familiar to you – you will probably be surprised at how much you can recognize. Second, it’s a sexy, modern story about obsession, with grit, passion and action and without any cliches such as consumptive heroines hacking up their lungs yet singing beautifully to the last*.
Taking place in Spain (though it’s in French), Carmen’s about a somewhat uptight, forthright soldier named José who’s supposed to arrest a trampy, trash-talking gypsy senorita (Carmen) for pulling a knife on a bitchy coworker in the local cigarette factory. She seduces the soldier into abandoning his duty and letting her go, and basically sends him down a road of self-destruction as they enter into an untidy but passion-filled affair.
Along the way there are smuggling thieves, an egocentric bullfighter who has the same intoxicating hold on Carmen that she does for José, attempts by the sweet girl-next-door who loves José (and whom his mom wants him to marry) to drag him out of the abyss of immorality, and an inevitably violent ending. And lots and lots of fiery, beautiful music.
There’s a famous movie directed by Francesco Rosi, with Placido Domingo (brilliant voice, excellent acting, and, um, sexy as hell) and Julia Migenes-Johnson (amazingly raw performance and every bit as sexy as Domingo) as the tempestuous pair of lovers.
Here’s a scene from the above film, early on when Carmen’s just been arrested. Don José is supposed to be watching over the prisoner before she’s moved to the garrison. Carmen, who’s tied up, ostensibly entertains herself by singing a harmless little song, but the whole time she’s inviting Jose to let her go and run away with her. Jose tries to resist, but … well. Carmen’s got quite a way with her. (Check out that smile at 1:51!) Migenes’s Carmen shows how much you can do with a wicked grin, va-va-voom figure and killer voice. Unfortunately in this video there aren’t any subtitles – there are subtitles in the film, but you can turn them off, and I guess this person did – but you really don’t need them to guess to know exactly what Carmen and her hopeless target Jose are saying to one another.
- Don’t yell at me: La Boheme is my favorite opera, and I love La Traviata too!