[QUOTE=jayjay]
Actually, I have a Sesame Street one, too. “We All Live In A Capital I”. The song itself is so melancholy, and all those poor people living in the desert with nothing to do all day but polish their “I” just made me sad.
[/QUOTE]
That one haunts me as well. (And curse Talon for finding a link to it, which I could not resist clicking on.)
Consider this too: that cartoon teaches you pretty much zilch about the letter “I”. It doesn’t show you common words with an “I” in them. Doesn’t talk about the different pronunciations “I” takes on, either by itself or in combination with the other vowels. Doesn’t show you a lower-case “i”. No, all you’ve learned by the end of the cartoon is that there’s this letter, and it’s named “I”, and here’s what its capital form looks like.
And, you’ve learned that it’s kept very clean, in the middle of the sky. By doomed souls who are condemned, for eternity it seems, to polish the damn thing over and over, toward no apparent purpose. Is this their personal hell, or merely a purgatory? What sins did they commit to deserve this? Are they being punished for having big egos in their past life? (Too much “I”, don’t you know.) Or are they truly beyond all hope? Have they been lobotomized or zombified so that they will always be happy idiots, polishing the “I”, numb to their pointless existence?
Do they, in the end, finally love Big I?
Do any letters really need cleaning anyway? Can’t we just make a new one pretty much anytime we want? There would seem to be an infinite supply of them. Or, is this special “I” the ultimate ur-I, the Platonic ideal “I”, without which no earthly “I” is conceivable? Should we be looking to the sky whenever we must render an “I”, to make sure we get it right? Will all I’s vanish if the ur-I is neglected? Or is it some sort of god, like Zeus, that must be pampered and appeased? What would be the nature of its vengeance, should it get a little filthy?
