Buffalo Billy Casper died yesterday. He’s in my top ten of all time for pro golfers.
Lots of Jack Nicklaus fans will tell you that Jack was the best golfer in the world for at least the first 20 years of his career, but he wasn’t. Casper was the best golfer in the world for half a dozen years or so, right in the middle of Jack’s prime.
Do you watch “Tiger Woods Golf” Sundays on NBC? Neither do I, because it doesn’t exist. But there was an NBC series starting in 1965 called “Big Three Golf,” that had Jack, Arnold Palmer, and Gary Player competing against each other. And the thing is, none of those three were as good as Casper during those years. Billy won 27 PGA events from 1964 to 1970, along with three Vardon Trophies, two money titles, and two Player of the Year awards (and he was easily the POY in 1968 as well, with six wins, the money title, and the Vardon, but the PGA didn’t award a POY that year because it was having a snit fit over the touring pros wanting more control over their careers). He also picked up his second US Open win and a Masters title during that period.
Like 90% of American golfers before Jack, he never bothered to play the British Open until late in his career, so he didn’t pick up the easy major wins against weak competition like Arnie, Jack, and Gary. At that time, the Western Open was a much bigger deal (for example, Casper was paid $11,000 for winning the Western in 1965, while Peter Thomson made just $4900 for winning the British), and he won three of those during that 7-year period. Most people today just count majors, not realizing the the British Opens and the PGAs of the 60’s had weaker fields than most of the regular tour events of the 60’s, let alone modern events like the WGCs.
By comparison, Jack won 24 individual events, zero Vardons, two money titles, and one POY. Arnie had 14 individual wins and one Vardon, Player had 6 wins.
In other words, during those 7 years, when all four were in their primes, Casper had more wins than any of them, more wins than Arnie and Gary combined, more Vardons than all three combined, and more POYs than all three combined, even after being denied a POY he undoubtedly deserved. And yet, he wasn’t in the “Big Three.” He’s got to be among the most underrated golfers ever.
From an article today:
"A brilliant putter with a superb short game as well, Casper was nonetheless overshadowed in his prime by Arnold Palmer, Jack Nicklaus and Gary Player. But he won 51 PGA Tour events between 1956 and 1975. Only Sam Snead, Nicklaus, Tiger Woods, Ben Hogan, Palmer and Byron Nelson won more PGA tournaments.
Casper played on eight Ryder Cup teams, winning 23.5 points, more than any other American, and he was the captain of the 1979 squad. He was the PGA Tour player of the year in 1966 and 1970, and he won the Vardon Trophy for best stroke average five times. He was the tour’s leading money winner twice, and he was inducted into the World Golf Hall of Fame in 1978.
Casper also won nine times on the senior tour, including two majors — the 1983 U.S. Senior Open and the 1988 Senior Tournament Players Championship. "