Continuing with my last Holiday rock book review, here is the Amazon link to **Yeah Yeah Yeah: The Story of Modern Pop from Bill Haley to Beyonce ** by Bob Stanley: http://www.amazon.com/Yeah-The-Story-Modern-Pop/dp/0571281974
Here is the thread on the Carrie Brownstein book, which links to my other rock bio reviews: Rock Bio: Hunger Makes me a Modern Girl by Carrie Brownstein - Cafe Society - Straight Dope Message Board
There is a lot going for this book, but it is not without its issues. Overall, it presents a nice overview of the U.S. and U.K. Bob Stanley is a member of the UK band St. Etienne as well as a music journalist. The fact of his Britishness means he can look at what was playing out in the U.S. from a bit of distance, and can speak to how US pop culture/music was reflected back in the UK.
His broad lens and depth of research are cool - he touches on a rich set of deep-cut names across a variety of musical genres based on how they hit the pop charts and/or had a lasting influence (he discusses Big Star, so pop success can’t have been his only criteria).
He generally picks off a year or a specific multi-year pop phenomenon, e.g., Motown or the British Invasion. He will focus on one or two acts that can illustrate that era best for his purposes, as well as connecting dots across musical genres. Again, the breadth of his knowledge is impressive.
This issues I have with it are the tone and some proofreading inaccuracies:
-
For the most part, his opinionated tone is really good. I agree with much of it, and his opinions lead to interesting connections and thoughts about specific songs. And his chattiness keeps the story tight and moving. But sometimes he will pop off with a dismissive opinion that clanks and seems bit too tossed-off to be discussed in a book that is kinda trying to be scholarly in a rock sort of way.
-
Proofreading inaccuracies: I came across enough that I ended up keeping track of some howlers:
-
Steve Miller- born in Milwaukee, and not Canadian as stated twice
-
Stevie Wonder played the clavinet synth on Superstition, not the clavichord, which was a proto-piano from 200 years ago.
-
He described the song “Horse with no Name” as an ecology song, not about a heroin bender
-
Roger McGuinn yes, he took his name Roger from airplane jargon, but based on religious teachings he had. Just tossing off that he named himself after an airplane word was a cheap shot
-
Washington DC’s Black Flag?? Rollins, yes, but the band was famously founded in SoCal
-
REO lyric for Keep On Loving You - he says it is “instead you lay still in the grass all coiled up and innocent” What?! That doesn’t even scan. It is actually “coiled up and hissin’”
So I wish he had a better proofreader. Overall, issues aside, I am glad I read it.