I’m involved in two threads now about Game of Thrones. One is about the HBO series and the books they are based on, and contains information (not hidden in spoiler boxes) that people who’ve only watched the show might not yet know. The other is just about the TV series, and the OP asks posters not to include any information that hasn’t appeared in an already aired TV episode.
By these criteria, neither need spoiler boxes – so long as posters respect the terms set by the OP in the latter thread. But that thread is currently risking derailment (it’s not a lost cause yet) because posters are unwilling to abide by the OP’s requested terms of posting.
FYI, for those who haven encountered spoiler boxes, the biggest problem IMO with using them is not within the thread itself, but with the email notices that come to your inbox with the test of new posts. In emails, the spoiler box coding doesn’t work, so it’s really easy to accidentally read their contents when you’re trying to avoid them.
This is bickering about using spoiler boxes is pretty common in a lot of threads. And I’d like to discuss whether there any rules that might be made to end the bickering.
What I would ideally like to see is OPs that are focused narrowly enough that no spoiler boxes are needed. If they aren’t used, there won’t be any unpleasant surprises when we open emails while not on the boards. The problem with this is that the OP has no authority to enforce a rule like that, and it seems some posters at least will not abide by it.
On a more general level, is there any fix to the spoilers not appearing in emails?
Would moderators be willing to enforce rules set for a particular thread, at the request of the OP? That would presumably include deleting the offending text or entire posts, based on rules set by a non-moderator? Even warning posters who consistently violate such rules. And yeah, I can see problems with this too.
Or maybe I’m making a mountain out a a molehill, and there’s no reason to promulagte new rules for such a minor problem.
Anyone care enough to add their thoughts?