Scientific basis for claim that eating meat makes blood acidic & causes bone loss?

Factual Questions
21

[QUOTE=Dr_Paprika]
… most meat eaters are not acidotic. Their lungs and kidneys have already compensated for the weak acid loads using normal buffering mechanisms.
[/QUOTE]

Thanks, that’s pretty much what I thought. Nice to have it officially confirmed.

[snerk] Welp, I’ll pass that along–I’m sure that after 6 years of eye rolling at the mere phrase “on the Straight Dope it says…” telling her “the Straight Dope says you have to learn to cook…” will have a lot of impact. :smiley:

22

[QUOTE=Cerowyn]
Gorillas eat insects as well, although by volume or weight, I believe it’s a fairly small percentage of their diet (with an adult male eating something like 50 lbs/22 kg of food a day).:
[/QUOTE]

Although the animal food eaten by gorillas is a tiny fraction in volume of the plant foods they consume, nutritionally it may be very important by containing certain beneficial / critical micronutrients not easily gotten from plant foods. I think the same may apply to us humans. One certainly does not need to eat lots of animal foods to enjoy good health, but a small amount can at least make it a whole lot easier to ascertain complete nutrition.

23

[QUOTE=Duck Duck Goose]
And I was even MORE fascinated to find on pp. 49-50, word-for-word her statements, above, about meat and acidic blood. She evidently simply copy-and-pasted it into her 2001 Being Vegetarian for Dummies.

She also copy-and-pasted word-for-word the remarkable statement, “The countries with the highest intakes of dairy products and animal protein also have the highest rates of hip fracture”, from her 1999 Idiot’s Guide to her 2001 Dummies. Apparently nobody ever told her that correlation is not causation.
[/QUOTE]

Indeed. The statement may even be true, but the cause not what she thinks. For example, if the countries with the highest intake of dairy and animal protein have significantly longer lifespans the fractured hips may be due more to the effects of extreme old age than diet.

24

Yeah, that was exactly what I thought, too. If you have better nutrition overall, then people live longer and have more chances to get broken hips.