Secret ballot, in my understanding. And yes, King and Sanders get votes.
Do the incoming freshmen get votes? How does that work?
Yes. Don’t have a cite handy. There’s nothing in the constitution about how the Senate picks its leaders, so they decide their own rules. The vote is secret, behind closed doors, and we don’t know how it went until it’s announced.
Another point: if you think voters voted blue because they’re happy with the Democratic party’s leadership, then it would make total sense that Schumer should stay. But in my understanding of the polling, that’s a ludicrous interpretation - the voters wanted change, and that includes change in Democratic party leadership as well.
Another thing I like about Van Hollen - he recognized, earlier than most Democratic senators, the injustice (and presumably the political salience) of the mistreatment of Kilmar Abrego Garcia, and his advocacy likely reduced the chance he might die in a Salvadoran gulag.
He was also an early endorser of Mamdani, which is more evidence he understands the political needs of the moment (and the views of most Democratic voters).
100% this. He wants a news cycle or so to build some name recognition. If AOC doesn’t run the progressive lane is up for grabs and he is looking to be its banner bearer with crossover appeal.
The Senate Democrats are not going to hand the wheel over to a self described progressive right now. And their theory of the case so to speak is not strengthened by the midterms.centrists overperformed relative to progressives.
Schumer will keep leadership He will push for accountability for the rampant corruption and he will do it carefully, being very clear that accountability and fighting corruption is not retribution and revenge. No martyrs created for MAGA. They hang themselves.
My perception is that actual policy differences between the “wings” are small - it is more how they get packaged rhetorically.
We want meaningful action taken and doing that requires unity among the Democrats AND a few Rs crossing over on key votes. Make that possible.
Assuming the democrats win the senate seat in AK, they will have 56 senate seats. So the new senate majority leader will need 29 democrats to win the position.
Currently I think only 13-16 democratic senators have come out as opposing Schumer as the majority leader. Hopefully that number grows, but we will see.
You know, I think what people are looking for is not really a speaker or a majority leader, it’s something like the British Shadow Cabinet. What we need is someone who can claim to be the leader of the Democrats when there is no Democratic president (and this goes for Republicans, too; I think Trump would have had auch harder time taking over their party if there was a leader of the Republican opposition to push back against him in 2015).
Schumer is unparalleled at whipping votes; we need him as leader of the Senate. What people are asking for is a figurehead to set the party’s direction and communicate about where the party is going and what it has accomplished. There’s no need for that to be a leader in the House or Senate (or even an elected official at all, to be honest).
Funny that all the Democrats who actually won those great victories are exactly the ones opposing Schumer! You can’t have it both ways; either he’s a leader of the Democratic Party who deserves credit for election victories or he’s a parliamentary functionary whose public approval is irrelevant to his qualifications for his job.
Slight hijack: I’d be happy to see Van Hollen as Majority Leader, but he’ll be 69 in two years, way too old to run for President.
Symbolism is a huge part of politics, and like it or not, Schumer is symbolic of the establishment and the past. Senators should take that into account as part of their decision.
Factually untrue.
Of the 13 new D Senators, all great victories, there are six who have stated they want change. One of them, Hamilton, saying he is too far Left, certainly not behind a Progressive. Of those 13 by my count 4 are clearly Progressive aligned, and one of those, Brown, has committed to Schumer.
Six is a significant number sure. But “all” is quite a hyperbolic stretch.
FWIW I agree it is time for generational change and hope that Schumer will step down before the next election. But it won’t happen now.
Many of the Democrats who oppose Schumer won by razor thin margins in solid blue seats. But they think they get to dictate terms! It’s laughable.
I count four (AES, Jackson, Stratton, Hamilton) who have explicitly said they won’t vote for Schumer and another four (Flanagan, Pappas, Talarico, Andrews) who have expressed a slightly vaguer desire for “new leadership”, so that’s 8 of 14. Colom hasn’t expressed an opinion, but has been very critical of the national Party’s failure to support his candidacy, and has also pushed back hard against Schumer’s attempts to take credit for having “recruited” Colom to run.
Sanders, Warren, and Slotkin are also on the record as wanting new leadership.
Per Wikipedia, the count stands at
14 for Schumer, of which Brown is the only freshman.
3 for Van Hollen (Sanders, AES, Flanagan)
11 uncommitted
5 uncommitted, but won’t vote for Schumer (Slotkin and the 4 mentioned above)
So that leaves 22 unaccounted for, which I guess probably means they haven’t said anything at all.
Which means only one-quarter of the caucus is currently publicly backing Schumer.
Who? I can’t think of a single one that qualifies here.
They should have a fight for it, preferably in the yard outside.
What a bizarre thing to say. No Democratic Senate candidates this year won by thin margins in solid blue States. The only one to win by less than 4% was Colom, in Mississippi. Jackson won by 6% in Maine and El-Sayed by 7% in Michigan, which are Dem-leading States but certainly not “solid blue”. Of the 8 Senators who have come out against Schumer, only Stratton and Sanders come from solidly Democratic States, as opposed to 3 from traditionally red States (Andrews, Talarico, Hamilton).
For what it’s worth, Colom (MS) denies that Schumer recruited him:
https://talkingpointsmemo.com/live-blog-update/colom-says-schumer-didnt-recruit-him-to-run
I’d count Andrews as a definite not wanting Schumer, and Flanagan is definitely not vague. Talarico and Pappas very vague.
So again quite far from “all” …
So he’s half way there publicly committed and says he has ample support in private conversations. Van Hollan has … three, I count four, I think Flanagan is a with him … and no path to get to the majority of the caucus. Even among those who don’t want Schumer many wouldn’t want him.
It’s a play for attention, not a real play for the job.
withdrawn
Well, here’s an article on Hamilton after he was elected:
Hamilton has said he doesn’t plan to support Schumer’s bid to be majority leader.
On Sunday, he said he has “no disrespect for Chuck Schumer,” but “I just really don’t [want him as majority leader], and I’ve told him that, as well.”
And another:
Adam Hamilton, the senator-elect from Kansas, told CNN on the campaign trail that he would not support Schumer as the party’s leader. Hamilton, the first Democrat to win a Kansas Senate seat in 94 years, had pitched himself as independent from the Democratic party.
Plus, anecdotally, I heard him say it at a rally in my hometown.