Sorry, I mixed up Colom with Hamilton and therefore withdrew that post.
Yes. Why waste time on futile “Impeachments”. Let the States handle corruption charges, where they can not be Vetoed or Pardoned.
If some GOP Moderates vote along with the Dems programs, that is great.
SCOTUS reform- vetoed or needs Constitutional amendment. Just not confirm any of trumps appointments after perhaps a couple of Justices leave.
New states- Vetoed
Wealth taxes are unfair and really foolish- only a few nations have them, a couple tried them, and got rid of them after they saw how bad they were. Instead, just increase the top levels Income tax.
Ooh “accountability”.
Congress can investigate, but not actually do anything. leave it to the States. And petty acts of vengeance is sooo trump-like, I thought we wanted to be less trump?
And how do you know what he will do some months from now?
Congress has a 8% approval rating. And 75? That is ageist.
Right.
Good idea- Investigations, let the States prosecute.
Van Hollen may not have a path to the majority, but clearly the majority is, at least publicly, undecided about Schumer. I suspect Van Hollen’s move may have been intended to make that clear to all involved.
Some people are implying that only “progressives” would want to dump a guy who’s incredibly unpopular and way past retirement age, but Slotkin and Hamilton certainly aren’t progressives, and I’d trade Schumer for either of them in a heartbeat.
Precedent is NOT public declarations of support. Has there ever been a leadership contest in which the lined up votes were even mostly publicly declared before the vote?
The current circumstance is exactly as expected for a very smooth endorsement of Schumer as Senate leader. There is no point being made; there is posturing for public consumption.
Schumer is likely to win, but likely is not certain, so we’ll see.
Senator Merkley supports Van Hollen:
https://talkingpointsmemo.com/live-blog-update/merkley-gets-behind-van-hollen-for-majority-leader
Posters keep talking about what the people want. What do we know about that? The main issues of the campaign were all negatives, Trump failures. Affordability, Iran, corruption. None of those issues are exclusively progressive. People want cost of living changes far more than getting into endless unwinnable battles for Trump.
What is progressive’s best battleground? The closest is Medicare for All, pushed heavily by El-Sayed and a few others. The idea of Medicare for All is supported by two-thirds of the public. There’s a huge asterisk to that. (Accurate AI summary of KFF polling.)
• Support rises to 76% if framed as guaranteeing health insurance as a right, and to 75% if framed as eliminating premiums and reducing out-of-pocket costs.
• Support drops to 52% if told it would eliminate private health insurance companies.
• Support falls to 38% if told it could threaten the current Medicare program.
• Support drops to 35% if told it would require most Americans to pay more in taxes.
• Support drops to 24% if told it could lead to delays in medical tests and treatments.
No change will or could be made before a Democratic president, who will need to have a fully formed coherent policy in place to explain to the public, over and over and over.
What other progressive policies stir voters? Raising minimum wages, renewable cheap energy, opposing data centers, a return to DEI, taking corporate money out of politics. All of these are also supported by centrists, though. Progressives can influence the details but they’re not going to do a radical reframing. The numbers just aren’t there. They will have no more than 10% of the Senate Democrats (and also no more than 10% of the House Democrats). That’s a fair proportional representation of the country as a whole, according to Pew’s typology.
Progressives seen to predominate in the places I read online, but there is no evidence that the country is there yet. What they need are a few leaders to present positive policies. Nobody stands out for me nationally. AOC is moving in that direction - notice she has pulled way back from her earlier positions and called Woke 1 “crazy” - but still niche. Mamdani is hugely popular and charismatic but can’t run for president. El-Sayed is unknown to most. Bernie Sanders and Elizabeth Warren are way too old.
Schumer will be Majority Leader, because a) that’s politics and b) he’s got the numbers.
While Medicare for All is not supported by moderates, universal healthcare through a public option (which lines up precisely with “guaranteeing health insurance as a human right”) absolutely is.
You’re ignoring the elephant in the room – Israel. It also isn’t a clear progressive division, but it is a very clear division between the pro- and anti-Schumer crowd. It is a big deal to Democratic voters, and it maps pretty closely to the division in the posters in this thread.
Hey, I sent him a message this week about it! Can I claim credit?
That’s the thing, isn’t it? Polls found majorities approving of the Affordable Care Act and majorities opposing Obamacare.
Not me. The voters. Israel was way down the list of concerns. The Iran war was a separate issue and that mostly for the price increases.
No question a big battle is coming up on Israel, but that will be pushed off until people see the consequences of the Israeli elections.
The Iran war and affordability is why the voters chose Democrats. Those issues farther down the list are why Democrats want Schumer versus someone else.
Even corruption doesn’t fall in Schumer’s favor. Rightly or wrongly, he is perceived as being part of the political machine that most voters think is corrupt to a greater extent than someone like Van Hollen.
But Obamacare was the ACA. The difference in polling there is simply due to branding.
I don’t think that’s the case with Medicare for All. M4A gets rid of private insurance, which most people don’t want.
Americans are in favor of a public option, not a single payer system.
This is one of the most pernicious ideas in politics: that power is given to people because they deserve it, or earned it, like a trophy. Seriously fuck that. This is too important to treat it like a prize. If he deserves a moment in the sun, set up a GoFundMe for a Chuck Schumer Caribbean vacation. The Majority Leader position should be decided solely on what’s going to lead to the best results for our country. If giving it to Steven Miller got us the best results, that’s what we should do, even though there’s never been a puppy-kickingier asshole in our nation.
I also disagree with any idea that, given Schumer’s overdog status, we should have an uncontested vote. There are obviously huge differences in the Democratic party right now, and this is a fantastic place to explore them, and the contest should be fought vigorously. Schumer and his allies are trying to make it seem inevitable in order to keep the contest from happening, and that’s not okay.
And this is one of the reasons I want Schumer to be gone: he’s playing politics with this in the worst possible way. Schumer is willing to distort the truth in order to hold onto personal power, and that’s exactly the kind of behavior that I don’t want the senate leader to engage in. Give me a good argument for him that’s honest, and I’ll consider it: my mind’s not made up. But so far, he’s not covered himself in glory.
I assume you meant “why Democrats want someone else other than Schumer” since you’re anti-Schumer.
Are they a majority of the Senate? If not, they don’t get to vote.
All I can do is to continuing repeating that Schumer will be the Majority Leader. Don’t be stupid about it when that happens. By all means encourage your senators to do what it is you want them to do. Do not - and I really mean this - do not spend all your time dumping on Schumer to the detriment of what he can accomplish. Trump and his idiot minions are going to fight every move Dems make, with tactics as foul as Ramaswamy’s.* Why make him fight Democrats at the same time?
* BENNY JOHNSON: Does the military and go and remove Ilhan Omar from Congress?
TOM EMMER: Yes! Yes! She is no longer allowed on the House floor
Off-topic post hidden
Schumer and Jeffries’ complete lack of reaction to the “investigation” of Ilhan Omar is emblematic of why a lot of Democrats want new leadership.
Van Hollen met Kilmar Abrego in prison while Schumer was sending out strongly-worded tweets.
That alone puts him above Schumer in my book.
Moderating:
@Gorsnak, I’ve hidden your post because it was very likely to lead to a major sidetrack. It is worthy of it’s own thread, but this thread is not about what’s going on in the House.
Schumer earlier this month said that “I actually had him and his father for lunch at my house in Brooklyn.”
That should be checkable and, if false, or in a time frame that could not fit, Schumer wasn’t distorting the truth to hold onto personal power, but rather destroying his chances.
In May 2025, Schumer suggested,through the New York Times,that Colom run:
How Democrats Hope to Overcome a Daunting 2026 Senate Map
Mr. Schumer has told associates that he sees an intriguing opportunity in Mississippi, which has the largest percentage of Black residents of any state. One possible candidate there is Scott Colom, a district attorney who was appointed by President Joseph R. Biden Jr. to a federal judgeship — only to be blocked by Senator Cindy Hyde-Smith, whom Mr. Colom would be running against in 2026. The state is also appealing for Democrats because it is small and relatively cheap to compete in.
But I do have a complaint regarding Schumer. Chuck should never have said that he recruited Colom to run. That’s because in Mississippi, a statewide Democrat needs to distance themselves from the party to have a reasonable chance of a long career.
Are they a majority of the Senate? If not, they don’t get to vote.
This is a truism masquerading as a prescription.
Of course they don’t get to vote, but it’s called “representative democracy” for a reason. If the system is working properly, their votes represent what their constituents want. If their constituents want someone besides Schumer, their constituents can’t vote of course, but their representatives in the senate ought to take that duty seriously.