Call me Cassandra, but I’m telling you what’s going to happen - not what I want to happen.
Why quote me? I am not saying there should be anything. I am simply stating what is: there is no real threat to Schumer being the Senate majority leader; Van Hollen doesn’t believe he has a chance; he is running for the position as an act of political theater.
I think Schumer should step aside and I believe that a contest for leadership would not have a progressive winning. But that also is not what is.
I think you have no evidence (at least nothing that’s remotely persuasive instead of circumstantial) for any of these claims. I’m quoting you because you say it’s not a real play for the job, and as far as I can tell, all the evidence points in the opposite direction.
I agree with all of this. Schumer is pretty insistent that he already has the votes to be Majority Leader, and given all of his experience and all that he knows and all the work he does behind the scenes, I don’t think that’s just overconfidence.
Making the pitch for his reelection, Schumer has been working with Democratic senators one-on-one to form an agenda for 2027. In private caucus meetings this week, Schumer opened discussion on a broad plan for their first 100 days in power that included healthcare and tariff legislation and efforts to stop the Iran war.
“I’m going to win it,” Schumer told The Associated Press in an interview last week.
That being said, like you I’d prefer if someone else were to take the reins. I don’t mean someone who will suddenly take the Senate into a hard left direction, but just someone who isn’t looking to keep the status quo. Schumer gives off “we must maintain decorum” vibes like Merrick Garland. I don’t think that’s going to cut it with this administration. But it’s almost surely going to be what we’re going to have.
Even Van Hollen has made it clear that he knows that he is the “underdog”, which implies to me that he knows Schumer is likely to win.
The historical record has how many successful challenges to Senate party leadership? It’s a round number - zero. Even after huge losses and loud discontent Reid staved it off.
How big is the contingency that wants a progressive as leader? Not big. Not half.
Schumer says he has the votes and in the past when the leader says he has the votes the votes have been there.
Van Hollen had been very open about his intention to run for the presidential nomination. The sudden nah I want Senate leadership? Could be sincere but he’s no idiot. Being the first to succeed in that bid when the current leader has just been in charge over a very successful midterms? That’s not just underdog status. It does however get his name known as someone wanting to fight the establishment.
Do you have a cite for this actual claim, or for a much weaker claim?
Again: you’re suggesting that because this fight hasn’t been won before, nobody would sincerely engage in it. I think that’s defeatist thinking and ignores what’s happening right now.
To the idea he “led” Democrats to a great victory I say phooey. The excellent candidates who ran are responsible for their victories.
And as far as I’m concerned the reason this should be a discussion is because of Schumer’s capitulation to Trump and the MAGA GOP in November of 2025 that allowed them to gut ACA tax credits. That was the betrayal that turned me against him and Durbin, my soon to be former Senator.
It is well past time for new leadership in the Senate.
There have been about ten to fifteen who are center right Democrats, breaking to vote with the GOP several times. Many more plain center and center left. I don’t think a cite is needed for the desire of the center left establishment folk to stay at the wheel.
As for his having had been planning as presidential nomination run -
His planning a run has not been subtle.
Today (that’s your cite) he says no, Senate leadership. Again could be sincere. Yeah could be. Uh huh.
Is Schumer responsible for the big victories that have occurred under his leadership? Probably not. But wins of seats are Senate leadership’s “it’s the economy stupid” - and leadership gets credit or blame whether they are responsible or not.
That’s a much weaker claim.
Of course the establishment folk want to stay at the wheel. But there’s no evidence that the establishment makes up more than half of the Dems in the senate.
Your theory that he’s doing it for show is predicated on his being a liar. I’m not willing to grant that without clearer evidence.
Note that Schumer is already the Incumbent. No one is “giving him power”, he already has it, and he did a great job. Changing him will just show a sign of weakness to the MAGAs.
Right, great point.
https://thehill.com/homenews/campaign/6218515-colom-denies-schumer-recruitment/
“He did initially understand that our party has to look south for future leadership,” Colom told MS NOW’s Symone Sanders Townsend in an interview that aired Thursday. “I think that it’s not accurate to say he recruited me, though.”… “I push back on the idea that I was recruited, not as a disrespect to anybody, but just as an acknowledgement that the people of Mississippi are the folks that deserve the credit,” he added.
The Senate Democratic leader was part of a strong performance in the midterm elections. Democrats not only won back the chamber but did so with seats to spare.
Schumer recounted in an interview with The New York Times how he recruited Democratic candidates across the battleground races to ensure his party would be best positioned to reclaim the upper chamber. In the story, the Times said Schumer recruited Colom.
So, saying “Colom (MS) denies that Schumer recruited him” needs some clarification. It is nuanced.
Right.
I mean, this IS sorta the standard line with ambitious national-level politicians. Every demurral is taken as either slightly or very disingenuous.
Me: Ossoff has repeatedly and firmly said he isn’t running for president in 2028.
Others (in so many words): Yeah, right - and I have a bridge in Brooklyn I want to sell you.
Me, after the election: Oh, the Democrats won the governorship in Georgia. Now Ossoff has plausible cover to change his mind about running for president in 2028.
So, even I do it. Politicians are just sorta assumed to be lying about their ultimate ambitions. Because focus on the immediate goal plays better than baldly stating that of course they are considering the optics on each public move that could help them towards gaining a higher office, which yes they absolutely want. Uncharitable? Yeah. Cynical? Yeah. Excessively cynical? Arguable.
Heh. The only person in this thread not thinking about running in 2028 is Schumer.
Okay here:
Let’s call everyone from Schumer to less progressive as broadly center and left if that progressive. Before this election 26 to 20 with Schumer as the dividing point to less progressive than he is. That more progressive group includes Tammy Baldwin, Ossoff, and Warnock FWIW. And more centrists won than progressives for the incoming class.
Definitely more than half.
This is a very seat-of-the-pants set of stats. First, did centrists replace Republicans, centrists, or progressives? Did progressives replace Republicans, centrists, or progressives? If progressives and centrists both replaced centrists, that doesn’t get you anywhere.
And if there are 56 senators, and 26 are Schumer or further right, and if progressives and centrists both replaced centrists, that makes 28 that are to the left.
But even if you’re right, it’s unclear that the current establishment best stays in power by backing the current establishment. There was a sea change in American politics last week, and the savvy players are noticing it. Schumer has a vested interest in pretending it didn’t happen, but others who might otherwise back him might decide to hitch their sails to a different ship, so to speak, out of a belief that backing the progressive is the best way for Democrats to stay in power. Schumer’s not super popular in the general public right now; if they back Hollen, maybe they improve the Democratic “brand” (yuck) and improve their own ability to stay in the establishment.
At this point, it looks to me like you’re building a case on very flimsy evidence. I’m not saying that Schumer’s out; I’m just saying that the confidence is unwarranted.
This attitude that “Schumer has the votes so let’s move on” is infuriating. It’s why so many Gen Z kids tune out on politics and don’t bother to vote. The establishment has spoken, don’t rock the boat, fall into line.
We didn’t get hundreds of thousands (millions?) of new voters who were inspired enough to vote this election because they wanted Democrats to be moderate and stick with politics as usual. “I really hope the Democrats stick with the establishment and keep doing what they’ve done for the last 10 years” said no one, except a bunch of old people.
Who cares what Van Hollen’s motivation is? It’s nothing more than an attempt to talk about something other than Schumer and the establishment. Let the Senate talk about what kind of leadership is needed. Have the discussions and arguments about how to combat the corruption, what healthcare plan is best, what role corporate lobbyists should have, etc. Maybe Schumer still wins in the end, but at least show voters that some senators are fighting for them.
Isn’t this exactly what the Senate Democrats will do inside the closed-door meeting where they will vote?
Sorry. I get that the intention is to display public distrust and outright hatred of whoever gets the job, and undermine any chance of unity at a time when it is desperately needed. The Freedom Caucus is the model.
Jeffries and Schumer aren’t going to fuck this up for us. Progressives will fuck this up and be proud to take credit for the Democrats failing again.I don’t know anybody who voted for a centrist! Never compromise! Principles before politics!
And you say you want new stuff. Sounds like the same old song to me.
Don’t know what your intention is, but it’s insulting to suggest that this is mine.
What a bizarre straw man.
No, they wanted less inflation, cheaper fuel, the end to the stupid war, and …get rid of trumpism. The Dems have not had a chance to do any of those things since trump and the GOP were in power.
My hope is that there’s enough of a push from progressives that it at least shifts Schumer’s priorities.